Agenda - Environmental Sustainability Committee Source: https://www.langleycity.ca/media/file/september-2024-esc-agenda Archived copy: https://heylangley.ca/records/city-of-langley/committees/environmental-sustainability-committee/2024/2024-09-01-agenda-september-2024-esc-agenda.pdf SHA-256 of the PDF: 4cc3d1a783ce9c20120fb5b45eb63c8fa8533460d26f5c97503ec805f3c8a281 Fetched: 2026-11-11 --- page 1 --- Document Number: 193561 ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY COMMITTEE THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 12, 2024 AT 6:00 p.m. Langley City Hall 20399 Douglas Crescent, Langley, BC A G E N D A 1) LAND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 2) AGENDA Adoption of the September 12, 2024 agenda 3) MINUTES Adoption of the minutes of the Environmental Sustainability Committee meeting held June 13, 2024 4) DISCUSSION 1. Urban Forestry MGMT Strategy Draft 2. Metro Vancouver’s Reducing Emissions from Small Gas-Powered Equipment Presentation 3. Earth Day 4. Bat Friendly Community Certification 5) STANDING ITEMS N/A 6) ROUND TABLE N/A ADJOURNMENT FUTURE MEETING DATES • October 10, 2024 • November 14, 2024 Please notify Natasha Loewen at nloewen@langleycity.ca of your confirmed attendance to be able to meet the quorum requirements to hold the meetings. --- page 2 --- Urban Forest Management Strategy Draft v3.3 Draft v3.3 August 2024 August 2024 --- page 3 --- Land Acknowledgement The City of Langley as we know it today is located on the unceded traditional territories of the q ̓ ʷɑ:n ̓ ƛ ̓ ən ̓ (Kwantlen), Máthxwi (Matsqui), q ̓ ic ̓ əy ̓ (Katzie) and e’mya’me (Semiahmoo) First Nations. Project Acknowledgement Diamond Head Consulting Ltd. (DHC) has prepared this Strategy for the City of Langley. DHC acknowledges the support and participation of City of Langley departments and staff in preparation of the document. --- page 4 --- Glossary Biodiversity Biodiversity is a term used to describe the variety and variability of life on Earth. Biodiversity encompasses all living species and their relationships to each other. This includes the differences in genes, species, and ecosystems. Canopy cover A measure of the extent of the urban forest based on the amount of ground covered by the foliage of trees when viewed from above. Ecosystem services The benefits to humans provided by the natural environment and healthy ecosystems. Carbon sequestration, recreation, shade, water filtration, and pollination are all examples of ecosystem services associated with the urban forest. Green infrastructure Natural and semi-natural areas with environmental and engineered features designed and managed to enhance nature’s ability to deliver a wide range of ecosystem services 1 . Impervious surface A surface that does not permit the infiltration of water or air needed by tree roots. Asphalt and concrete are common impervious surfaces. Invasive species A species that is not native or is outside of its natural range and is negatively impacting the environment. LiDAR Acronym for ‘light detection and ranging’. An active remote sensing technology that can measure vegetation height and elevation using laser scanning. Natural asset Natural assets are the stock of natural resources or ecosystems that are relied upon, managed, or could be managed by a local government for the provision of one or more services to a community 2 . Tree equity When all people can access the benefits of the urban forest in proportion to their needs. Urban forest program A set of activities performed by City staff and community partners to plan, manage, enhance, protect, and steward the urban forest, as well as all related policies, equipment, resources and knowledge used to work towards Langley City’s urban forest vision. --- page 5 --- iv City of Langley Executive Summary --- page 6 --- v Urban Forest Management Strategy The City of Langley is home to a diverse urban forest anchored by the Nicomekl River corridor at its centre, and growing outwards through a network of natural areas, streets, parks, and private properties. This urban forest offers significant benefits to the community, including high levels of biodiversity, recreational opportunities, improved air quality, stormwater management, and enhanced neighbourhood aesthetics. Langley City’s Official Community Plan sets a goal to “expand and strengthen the existing tree canopy.” In meeting this goal, the urban forest faces growing challenges from climate change and densification to accommodate a growing population. At the same time, redevelopment presents opportunities to increase canopy cover in under-served areas north of the Nicomekl River. To respond to growing challenges and emerging opportunities, the City of Langley has developed an Urban Forest Management Strategy that establishes a long-term vision and guidance for urban forest growth and management in the decades to come. In 2021, Langley City’s tree canopy cover was estimated to be 17%. This Strategy provides a 30-year vision and supporting goals, strategies and actions to achieve a baseline canopy cover target of 20 % by 2046 and an aspiration target of 31% by 2050. Implementing this Strategy will enhance the management of public tree assets to maximize tree benefits and minimize risks, and expand opportunities to protect and grow tree canopy on public and private land in partnership with the community. Langley City’s urban forest features a wealth of mature trees and a diversity of native and climate-adapted species that foster a healthy, connected community and ecosystems, delivering benefits to all residents. VISION GOALS --- page 7 --- vi City of Langley A total of 33 actions are proposed to be implemented over the next 15 years, including some actions that will have the biggest impacts on the City’s urban forest as well as some ‘quick start’ actions that allow quick initiation of the implementation: More detailed actions can be found in the The Implementation Plan in the appendix. --- page 8 --- vii Urban Forest Management Strategy Contents Glossary iii Introduction 1 Current State of Langley City’s Urban Forest 3 What is the Urban Forest? 4 Why is the Urban Forest Important? 5 A Brief History of the Urban Forest 7 Urban Forest Management 8 Tree Canopy Cover 11 Canopy Cover Change 16 Opportunities and Challenges 17 Community Values and Priorities 19 Phase 1 Engagement Summary 20 Langley City’s Urban Forest Management Strategy 22 Vision and Goals for the Future 23 Canopy Target 24 Urban Forest Strategies and Actions 25 The Implementation Plan 31 Conclusion and Recommendations 36 References 39 Appendices 40 1. Urban Forest 101 41 2. Policies and regulations that guide urban forestry 43 3. The State of the Urban Forest 46 4. Engagement Summaries 69 --- page 9 --- 1 Urban Forest Management Strategy 1 Introduction --- page 10 --- 2 City of Langley The City of Langley’s diverse urban forest is composed of forested ecosystems and urban trees growing along streets, parks, and on private properties. The urban forest beautifies the city, improves community well-being, and provides essential habitat for wildlife. However, the escalating impacts of climate change—including droughts, storms, and the prevalence of invasive species, pests and diseases — are impacting urban forest health. Additionally, urban densification makes it more challenging to retain and replant trees. This is the City of Langley’s first Urban Forest Management Strategy and it responds to current challenges and opportunities by establishing a vision to guide city- wide urban forest growth and management to 2050. Implementing the Urban Forest Management Strategy will ensure Langley has a healthy, diverse, and resilient urban forest in the next 30 years. The Urban Forest Management Strategy includes the following sections: 1. Introduction : Introduces the Urban Forest Management Strategy; 2. Current State of Langley City’s Urban Forest : Describes the urban forest and its key components, a historical timeline of the urban forest, its current condition, and the key opportunities and challenges that the City faces to achieve its urban forest vision and goals; 3. Community Values and Priorities : Summarizes the feedback from the community through the public engagement process. 4. Langley City’s Urban Forest Management Strategy : outlines the vision for the urban forest, and supported goals, strategies, and actions to achieve the vision over a 30-year timeframe. 5. Conclusion and Recommendations : Concludes the Strategy with recommendations on the implementation and monitoring of the Strategy. --- page 11 --- 3 Urban Forest Management Strategy Current State of Langley City’s Urban Forest 2 --- page 12 --- 4 City of Langley What is the Urban Forest? Figure 2 Langley City’s urban forest Urban forests include all trees and their associated ecosystems. Langley City’s urban forest includes all trees and native forests in natural areas, parks, schools, streets, and private yards across the city ( Figure 2 ). The City’s urban forest contains diverse species of trees and understory vegetation and grows across public and private land, meaning that both the City and community members are responsible for its management. In fact, two-thirds of Langley City’s estimated 49,000 trees grow on private lands. Trees, much like other types of city assets, require regular maintenance to maximize the benefits they provide the community and ensure a long service life. Strategic care can prolong a tree’s life, enhancing its ecological, social, and economic contributions. The City manages trees along road rights-of-way and in city parks, while private property owners care for those on private land. Management approaches differ based on where trees grow. Trees in natural areas are typically managed as stands, focusing on forest health (e.g., managing invasive species) and minimizing risks at forest edges and along trails. In contrast, urban trees, often planted individually, require more intensive care like pruning and watering due to their proximity to buildings and people. This approach ensures tailored management to diverse urban forest environments. More details on the management of Langley City’s urban forest are provided in Appendix 1. --- page 13 --- 5 Urban Forest Management Strategy Why is the Urban Forest Important? The urban forest, sometimes described as a ‘natural asset’, is a key contributor to a healthy and sustainable community. The urban forest supports urban cooling, stormwater management, biodiversity and wildlife habitat, slope stability and flood mitigation. These processes, and the broader array of community benefits that urban forests provide, are often called ‘ecosystem services 3 .’ In the City of Langley, the urban forest plays a vital role in maintaining a comfortable environment for urban residents and wildlife. Trees cool their surroundings by blocking sunlight and releasing water vapour, reducing the need for energy-intensive air conditioning in the summer 4 . Trees and soil play a key role in stormwater management, capturing and filtering contaminants. Reducing stormwater runoff is especially important during heavy rainfalls that can lead to flooding 5 . The City’s forested areas support various plant and animal species, contributing to local biodiversity 6 and forming green corridors for wildlife movement, promoting genetic diversity and ecosystem resilience. Trees provide habitat, enhancing ecological diversity and offering food and shelter to many species of native flora and fauna that are essential for ecological balance, nutrient cycling, and pollination. The urban forest also contributes significantly to social well-being and community resilience. It offers communal spaces for interaction, recreation, and relaxation. These green spaces enhance physical and mental health, beautify the city, attract visitors, and potentially boost commercial activity 7 , 8 . Figure 3 Illustration of urban forest benefits --- page 14 --- 6 City of Langley Valuing Ecosystem Services Software developed by the US Department of Agriculture’s Forest Service allows us to quantify the value of a few of Langley’s City’s urban forest benefits. In 2021, the City’s urban forest provided an estimated $3.7 million worth of benefits and services in carbon storage and sequestration, stormwater management, and pollutant removals (Table 1). The entire urban forest acts as a substantial carbon sink, storing over 13,000 tonnes of carbon or over 49,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent, an estimated value of $3.2 million. Each year, the urban forest sequesters 450 tonnes of carbon from the atmosphere (estimated at $107,300), intercepts or absorbs over 48 million litres of runoff (estimated at $147,600), and removes over 15 million grams of air pollutants (estimated at $227,000). Ecosystem Service Service Estimates Dollar Value ($) CARBON Carbon stored in trees (t) 13,399 $3,196,300 CO2 equiv. rate (t) stored in trees 49,129 $3,193,400 Carbon sequestered in trees (t/year) 450 $107,300 CO2 equiv. rate (t/year) sequestered annually in trees 1,649 $107,200 STORMWATER Avoided runoff annually (L/year) 48,563,059 $147,600 POLLUTION Removed air pollutants (g/ha/year) 15,364,150 $227,000 CO removed annually (g/year) 135,997 $300 NO2 removed annually (g/year) 1,372,173 $500 O3 removed annually (g/year) 9,711,566 $37,100 PM10 (g/year) 2,868,137 $25,500 PM2.5 (g/yr) 749,726 $163,500 SO2 removed annually (g/year) 526,552 $100 Total Annual Service Value $481,900 Total Service Value $3,678,200 Table 1 Results of i-Tree Canopy assessment Did you know that Langley City’s urban forest: • Offsets emissions from 360 average passenger vehicles in a year • Can prevent runoff equivalent to water that fills 19 Olympic swimming pools per year --- page 15 --- 7 Urban Forest Management Strategy Figure 4 Aerial view looking north towards Langley City in 1973 (source: Langley Centennial Museum) A Brief History of the Urban Forest The lands now known as the City of Langley have been inhabited and cared for by the Stó:lo First Nations, particularly q ̓ ʷɑ:n ̓ ƛ ̓ ən ̓ (Kwantlen), since time immemorial. Prior to European settlement, the Langley’s lowland floodplains and adjacent uplands hosted natural habitats including rivers, ponds, swamps, marshes, and forests. The arrival of settlers in the early 1800s profoundly changed the natural landscape as forests were cleared for agricultural and, eventually, urban land uses as the City became the downtown core for the surrounding area. Agriculture boomed in the fertile valley soils and native forests dominated by Douglas fir, western redcedar, western hemlock, and Sitka spruce were logged extensively. Although some natural areas remain, most of the forest ecosystems within the municipality are altered and fragmented compared to their historic state. However, the City still retains a variety of natural habitats, mostly concentrated around the Nickomekl River and its tributaries, in addition to parks, gardens, and other open space. Today, the City of Langley is also home to a diverse mix of planted urban trees growing along streets, in parks, and on private lands. Many of these urban trees were planted relatively recently and will grow the City’s urban tree canopy over the coming decades. In 1999, the City took a significant step in managing its urban forest by initiating a street tree program to preserve and enhance the street trees in the City. A preliminary tree inventory was carried out in the summer of 1999, marking one of the first efforts by the City to compile information for urban forest management. While the street tree inventory is no longer current, the implementation of this Urban Forest Management Strategy will result a renewed focus on both urban trees and trees growing in remnant forest ecosystems. --- page 16 --- 8 City of Langley Urban Forest Management Langley City’s urban forest is managed by a dedicated team that cares for City-owned trees and is guided by a set of policies and regulations that inform the City’s approach to tree protection and management. Urban Forest Management Program In the City of Langley, the Engineering and Parks Operations Department takes the lead in protecting and managing the urban forest. Out of the estimated 49,000 trees in the City, about one-third (estimated 16,500 trees) are found on public properties and mainly managed by the City. City- owned tree assets include about 6,000 street trees, 2,400 park trees, and 8,100 trees on other City properties. New trees are added to the City’s asset portfolio in new parkland or on the street frontage of new developments after they are planted and maintained by developers. The primary responsibilities of the Engineering and Parks Operations Department include tree planting, replacement, pruning, watering, and removal on City-owned properties, such as parks and roads. The dedicated team includes the Parks Manager, Parks Superintendent, a Head Arborist and an arborist crew. Additional staff support the core team during storm removals, fall pruning or planting practices. Temporary staff are sometimes hired to supplement these efforts when necessary. In recent years, the urban forestry team has been increasingly involved in the development permit review process to ensure appropriate site design considerations for tree retention and replacement. The City allocates an annual operational budget of $112,700 for tree pruning, $80,760 for hazardous tree removal, and $105,340 for planting. To sustain its urban forest, the City often allocates a capital budget for tree replacement, which was set at $40,000 in 2023. Young trees are managed more actively, with staff doing structural pruning annually for the two to three years after planting. Young tree watering has been extended from two to eight years after planting to allow the trees to establish in the region’s increasingly warm, dry climate. Maintenance of established trees is primarily reactive, meaning that staff visit the trees for pruning or risk inspections when they receive a request for service or by visiting areas where they have noticed issues. Between 2016 and 2023, the City received an average of 186 tree-related work orders per year. Although the numbers varied by year, over 80% of the work orders were about tree pruning and tree removals, with the remainder related to issues like pests and insects or requests for tree watering. --- page 17 --- 9 Urban Forest Management Strategy Policies and Regulations Urban forest management in Langley City is guided by a set of plans, policies, and bylaws ( Figure 5 ). These documents guide how trees, forests, and lands in the City are managed and protected. Langley City can make regulations about trees due to enabling legislation from the Province. Guiding policies and plans focus on the vision and big ideas for the City’s trees and natural areas. Bylaws, policies, and guidelines help put these big ideas into action. Other plans and policies associated with themes such as climate change and transportation also influence the outcomes of urban forest management in Langley City. The Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw and Design Criteria Manual sets requirements to tree planting on streets adjacent to developing properties, while the Development Permit Areas guide the protection of Environmentally Sensitive Areas (ESAs) and tree planting during development on private land. Appendix 2 provides a more detailed overview of policies and regulations that guide urban forest management in the City of Langley. Enabling Legislation Local Government Act Community Charter Guiding Policy and Plans Interim Strategic Plan 2021-2022 Strategic Plan 2017-2021 Official Community Plan (OCP) Parks, Recreation, and Culture Master Plan Sustainability Framework Bylaws and Policies Design Criteria Manual Zoning Bylaw Development Permit Area (DPA) Guidelines Parks and Public Facility Regulation Bylaw Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw Floodplain Elevation Bylaw Environmentally Sensitive Area DPA Guidelines Associated Plans, Policies, and Guidelines Nature Trail Network Plan Integrated Stormwater Management Plan Master Transportation Plan Community Energy and GHG Emissions Plan Form and Character DPA Guidelines Upper Nicomekl River Integrated Stormwater Management Plan Figure 5 Langley City plans, policies, and bylaws of importance for the urban forest --- page 18 --- 10 City of Langley Report card The report card provides a comprehensive assessment of the City’s urban forest program against industry best practices to identify areas where the City is performing well and where the Urban Forest Management Strategy should guide efforts for further improvement. Langley City ranks ‘fair’ for its complete program. The report card below summarizes the assessment of each indicator in Langley City’s current program against an optimal outcome. PLAN AND ADAPT Poor Fair Good Optimal Municipal infrastructure asset management Awareness of the urban forest Relative tree canopy cover Interdepartmental and municipal agency cooperation Municipal urban forestry program capacity Clear and defensible urban forest assessment and goals Municipality-wide management plan Municipal-wide biodiversity or green network strategy Funding to implement a strategy PLANT Poor Fair Good Optimal Selection and procurement of stock in cooperation with nursery industry City tree planting and replacement program Ecosystem services targeted in tree planting projects and landscaping Development requirement to plant trees on private land Equity in planting program delivery Forest restoration/native species planting Streetscape and servicing specifications and standards for planting trees MANAGE Poor Fair Good Optimal Tree inventory Species diversity of inventoried trees Knowledge of trees on private property Natural areas inventory Knowledge of health condition of inventoried trees Age/size cohort distribution of inventoried trees Maintenance of inventoried trees Emergency response planning Tree risk management Waste biomass utilization Pest and Disease management PROTECT Poor Fair Good Optimal Regulate sensitive ecosystems, soils or permeability through private development Regulate protection and replacement of private and City trees Standards of tree protection/care observed Cooperation with utilities Internal protocols guide City tree or sensitive ecosystems protection PARTNER Poor Fair Good Optimal Citizen involvement/neighbourhood action Regional collaboration Urban forest research Involvement of land holders Climate suitability of inventoried trees 2023 URBAN FOREST REPORT CARD P O O R F A I R G O O D O P T I M A L In progress Insufficient data In progress In progress Insufficient data Insufficient data Insufficient data Carbon footprint tracking --- page 19 --- 11 Urban Forest Management Strategy Tree Canopy Cover The following section provides a snapshot of Langley City’s urban forest today using canopy cover as the main metric. Canopy cover measures the land area covered by tree branches and leaves when viewed from above ( Figure 6 ). It is one of the most common metrics in urban forestry to assess and track the extent of the urban forest over time. Langley City’s canopy cover was estimated using a combi - nation of aerial imagery and remotely sensed Light Detec - tion and Ranging (LiDAR) data collected in 2016 and 2021. For more details about the current state of the ur ban forest, including information about forest stands (e.g., forest structure and type), as well as the data used to generate the urban forest metrics discussed in this section , please refer to Appendix 3. Figure 6 Illustration of tree canopy cover --- page 20 --- 12 City of Langley Citywide Canopy Cover Langley City’s 2021 canopy cover was estimated to be 17% citywide (174 hectares), with most of the canopy located south of the Nicomekl River ( Figure 7 ). An estimated 49,000 trees distributed across public and private land provide the City’s canopy cover. Langley City’s urban forest is primarily deciduous, with deciduous trees providing 61% of the total canopy cover. Deciduous trees are located on private land, along streets, parks, and other public areas. Coniferous trees, on the other hand, are more commonly found on private properties, especially in the southern section of the City. Figure 7 Canopy cover of Langley City in 2021 Langley City’s 2021 canopy cover 17% --- page 21 --- 13 Urban Forest Management Strategy Who Owns the City’s Tree Canopy? Two-thirds of Langley City’s land is privately owned and 64% of the tree canopy grows on private land ( Figure 8 ). Public land accounts for one-third of the city’s land area, and holds the remaining 36% of the tree canopy. The high proportion of tree canopy under private ownership means that successful implementation of the Strategy will require actions be taken on both City and privately managed land alike. Figure 8 Canopy cover and land area of public and private lands How does Langley City’s canopy compare to other municipalities in the region? Metro Vancouver’s 2020 regional canopy cover study estimated the region’s canopy cover at 31% within the Urban Containment Boundary (the area where urban development is concentrated to manage growth and restrict sprawl 17 ). The regional data shows that Langley City has canopy cover comparable to municipalities like White Rock and Port Coquitlam, which support a similar population density ( Figure 10 ). Metro Vancouver’s report suggests that Langley could pursue a canopy cover target of 35% by 2050 to help achieve the region’s 40% target. However, the regional data over-estimates Langley’s current canopy cover 1 , and work completed to prepare this Strategy does not support a 35% target being possible within the 2050 timeframe. 1 The regional study provides a coarser estimate of canopy cover compared to the dataset prepared for this strategy. As a result, the statistics from the regional study (21% canopy cover) and this report (17% canopy cover) are not directly comparable.. UCB Average % 2020 Tree Canopy Cover Figure 10 Canopy comparison (within UCB) across Metro Vancouver in 2020 Figure 9 Public and private lands within Langley City --- page 22 --- 14 City of Langley Canopy Cover Distribution Canopy by Neighbourhood The distribution of tree canopy across Langley City’s neighbourhoods follows a strong north- south gradient ( Figure 11 ). Neighbourhoods in the south part of the City, such as Simonds and Uplands enjoy the most abundant tree canopy at approximately 27%. In comparison, the Nicomekl and Douglas neighbourhoods north of the river have less than 15% canopy cover. Tree Equity American Forests developed the Tree Equity Score metric, which allows communities to assess how equitably their urban forest benefits are distributed (see Appendix 3 for more details). The metric combines data about the lack of canopy cover (canopy gap) with data about the highest need for trees to prioritize areas for tree planting. The areas with the highest need for trees have the hottest surface temperature and a high proportion of populations most vulnerable to heat impacts (seniors and children, unemployed, lower income, and minority groups). Figure 12 shows the Tree Equity Score for census dissemination areas across Langley City. Areas with the lowest tree equity are in the northern part of the City and around the downtown area. The Tree Equity Score can help inform tree planting priority during the implementation of Langley City’s strategy. Figure 11 Canopy cover by neighbourhood in 2021 Figure 12 Tree Equity Score by census dissemination area Tree Equity Score Lowest (higher need) Highest Canopy <10% 25-30% --- page 23 --- 15 Urban Forest Management Strategy Canopy by land use Langley City’s Official Community Plan (OCP) defines future land use ( Figure 13 ). Analyzing canopy cover based on these land use designations offers a perspective on potential tree impacts due to future development. PARKS AND OPEN SPACE LAND AND CANOPY AREA (HA) CANOPY PERCENTAGE SUBURBAN GROUND-ORIENTED COVER MIXED EMPLOYMENT AGRICULTURE SERVICE COMMERCIAL LOW RISE RESIDENTIAL URBAN RESIDENTIAL TRANSIT-ORIENTED RESIDENTIAL UNIVERSITY DISTRICT MIXED USE HISTORIC DOWNTOWN CORE CIVIC CENTER INDUSTRIAL TRANSIT-ORIENTED CORE MID RISE RESIDENTIAL 27% 187 169 75 69 58 50 44 39 36 34 22 12 11 11 5 3 50 45 3 13 12 2 1 7 1 10 3 2 2 1 0.05 0.1 27% 4% 20% 20% 3% 3% 18% 2% 30% 13% 19% 14% 8% 1% 4% Figure 14 Official Community Plan land use designations Figure 13 Land and canopy cover area and percentage for all OCP land use The land uses with the highest canopy cover include parks and open spaces, suburban areas, and urban residential, which had at least 27% canopy cover in 2021. Parks and open space and suburban land uses also make up a large proportion of Langley City’s total land area, meaning that any significant changes to canopy in these land uses would have significant impacts on the City’s canopy cover. Other land uses like mixed employment, transit-oriented core, or the historic downtown core have nearly no canopy cover. While those land uses face limitations for the space available to grow trees, opportunities may exist to increase tree canopy. --- page 24 --- 16 City of Langley Canopy Cover Change Canopy cover in Langley City decreased from 20% in 2010 to 17% in 2021. Detailed canopy data between 2016 and 2021 shows specific locations where canopy has grown or been removed in recent years ( Figure 15 ). The majority of the canopy loss was recorded within the suburban and low-rise residential OCP land uses, representing 40% and 31% of the total canopy change, respectively. The canopy loss in low-rise residential and possibly suburban parcels appears to be tied to increased redevelopment activities within these land uses. In contrast, parks and open spaces registered the highest canopy gain at 8%. Other land uses experienced minimal changes in their canopy cover. See Appendix 3 for more details (note that results differ from the 2020 Metro Vancouver analysis due to data resolution differences). Example of canopy loss for the development on a low rise residential parcel: Figure 15 Map of canopy change from 2016 to 2021 2016 2021 Example of canopy gain on older low rise and transit- oriented developments: 2016 2021 » » --- page 25 --- 17 Urban Forest Management Strategy Opportunities and Challenges This section describes current opportunities and challenges that Langley City will need to address or leverage to achieve the Strategy’s 2050 vision. Climate change Langley City’s urban forest is already experiencing impacts from the more common and prolonged droughts recently experienced in the region. Native species, such as the western redcedar, are already showing signs of distress across the region due to more frequent droughts. In addition to drought, more frequent extreme weather and the emergence of new pests and diseases could further threaten the urban forest. Langley City will need to continue proactively preparing for and adapting to the impact of climate change with strategies such as increasing watering of young trees, providing sufficient soil volumes to give trees good access to water, and planting a diversity of climate-adapted species. City tree management There is no asset inventory of street and landscape park trees, making it difficult to evaluate the condition and diversity of trees actively managed by City staff. A tree inventory and defined service levels help define budgets and priorities for management. While good collaboration exists between departments, tree protection and planting outcomes could be improved with better-defined processes and communication tools between departments. The Strategy will build on innovative approaches already being trialled by City staff, such as using microbial inoculants to improve tree health. --- page 26 --- 18 City of Langley Urban redevelopment Redevelopment presents both opportunities and challenges for Langley City’s urban forest. Recent trends in canopy cover show that the City has been losing canopy in part as a result of redevelopment, particularly in low-rise and suburban residential uses (see Figure 13 for OCP land use details), which have seen higher rates of development in recent years. New higher-density developments are also expected to have high site coverage that will limit tree planting opportunities on private parcels due to height restrictions from aeronautic regulations and limited opportunities for underground structures because of soil types and the depth aquifer. Despite these challenges, development will also present many opportunities to increase tree canopy. The City expects to see the most significant increase in population density in neighbourhoods north of the Nicomekl River, particularly along the planned Skytrain line. Given that those neighbourhoods have high impervious cover and low tree canopy, development could bring opportunities for greening through on- site planting, improved streetscapes, and new parkland acquisition. Past canopy trends have already shown that some previously redeveloped low- rise properties now show canopy gains from trees planted along the street or on the properties maturing. Private land stewardship and tree removals Much of Langley City’s canopy grows on private land. The City would benefit from adopting a tree bylaw to regulate the removal and replacement of trees on private land. A tree bylaw, combined with provisions for landscaping in zoning bylaws and/or development permit areas, could guide community expectations for tree retention and replacement on all properties and in the development context. Recent Provincial housing legislations, which promote increased housing density and streamlined development approvals, makes it essential to have clear guidance for tree protection and landscaping requirements with development. Partnerships Given that much of Langley City’s urban forest grows on private land and that City resources are limited, stewardship will continue to be an essential part of ensuring a healthy urban forest. The City can continue supporting community members and organizations in their stewardship of the urban forest and seek opportunities to partner with property owners such as schools. The City has a history of successful partnerships with institutions like Kwantlen University that it can build on to seek more partnerships with post-secondary institutions to document and improve urban forestry practices. --- page 27 --- 19 Urban Forest Management Strategy 3 Community Values and Priorities --- page 28 --- 20 City of Langley Public engagement plays a pivotal role in shaping the effective implementation of the Urban Forest Management Strategy. Recognizing this, the City of Langley has embarked on a comprehensive two-phase process to capture diverse voices and views, ensuring that strategy design aligns with the community’s needs, aspirations, and preferences. Phase 1, completed in July 2023, seeks to understand public values, vision, and priorities. The subsequent Phase 2 engagement will provide an opportunity to offer feedback on this draft strategy. The following section highlights the key engagement outcomes. Please refer to Appendix 4 for a complete summary. Phase 1 Engagement Summary Who We Heard From More than 205 people participated in Phase 1 engagement, including 196 survey respondents, 10 Environmental Sustainability Committee members and people who visited the pop-up booth and used the mapping tool. Of the 196 survey respondents, the large majority are within the 35-64 age group and reside in the City of Langley. The most represented neighbourhoods are Nicomekl and Simonds. A Vision for the Urban Forest Participants were asked what they wanted Langley’s urban forest to look like in 2050 ( Figure 16 ). In general, participants envisioned an expanding and healthy urban forest composed of diverse and native species that are large and mature. Other ideas raised were: • Providing shade and cooling • Supporting wildlife habitat and biodiversity • Enhancing walkability and access to greenspaces such as parks and walking trails Figure 16 Word cloud showing the most common words used by respondents to describe their vision of the urban forest by 2050 “A tall healthy forest, with a healthy understory of native berries and flowers. With lots of places for people to walk and spend time in, but also with restricted areas for ecological conservation and enhancement.” “Many trails with assorted tree sizes and species that attract wildlife such as bats and deer in park areas. Cultured trees in developed areas.” --- page 29 --- 21 Urban Forest Management Strategy Current Levels of Service Residents expressed mixed satisfaction with the services currently provided by the City of Langley ( Figure 17 ). While many appreciated the City’s response to storm and debris cleanup, they were more neutral or dissatisfied with other service levels such as pest and disease control and dangerous tree removals. Respondents were the most dissatisfied with the service of public education opportunities (9% satisfied and 35% dissatisfied). Figure 17 Satisfaction levels with current service levels for trees in parks and along streets (total respondents =155) --- page 30 --- 22 City of Langley Langley City’s Urban Forest Management Strategy 4 --- page 31 --- 23 Urban Forest Management Strategy Vision and Goals for the Future The vision that guides the implementation of Langley City’s Urban Forest Management Strategy is that: Langley City’s urban forest features a wealth of mature trees and a diversity of native and climate-adapted species that foster a healthy, connected community and ecosystems, delivering benefits to all residents. The vision is supported by four goals: --- page 32 --- 24 City of Langley Canopy Target Setting a canopy cover target is a common way for municipalities to monitor their success in implementing their urban forest management strategy. Leading organizations in the field of urban forestry, such as the US-based not-for-profit organization American Forests, recommend setting targets that are not only based on the region’s ecosystems and climate but also reflective of what is achievable given the municipality’s population density and land use constraints. Langley City’s Urban Forest Management Strategy sets a baseline and an aspirational canopy cover target for 2046 and 2050, respectively: 17% 20% 31% 2021 2046 2050 A s p i r a t i o n a l B a s e l i n e Langley City canopy cover Figure 1 Langley City’s baseline and aspirational canopy cover targets Baseline target: Langley’s baseline canopy cover target is to achieve 20% by 2046 with the implementation of the UFMS action plan. To achieve this target, Langley City will need approximately ~1,080 new trees annually across public and private land. This estimate is based on a forecast of development over the next two decades and may vary based on the actual pace of development. Trees planted during that timeframe will continue to grow and provide increased canopy cover beyond 2046. The baseline target means that: • Tree removed are being replaced • Additional new trees are being planted each year: » ~250 trees planted in City parks and rights-of-way by the City or with new developments » ~260 trees planted on private land through voluntary plantings or development Aspirational target: Metro Vancouver has established a 40% canopy target for the UCB by 2050 and recommends that Langley City increase its canopy cover from the current level to 35% by 2050 to help achieve this regional goal. 15 Langley City will work towards that aspirational target as resources permit, for example by seeking external funding to support more tree planting. --- page 33 --- 25 Urban Forest Management Strategy Urban Forest Strategies and Actions The following section provides an overview of urban forest strategies and actions the City aims to implement to achieve its vision and goals. A detailed implementation plan is included in Appendix 4. Goal 1 Protect and enhance trees, forests, and soils to connect ecosystems and deliver community benefits Strategies and actions under Goal 1 focus on improving policies and regulations that protect existing trees and ensure new trees are planted across the City. The actions seek to improve tree protection and planting in urban areas (i.e., along streets and in yards) and within natural areas. The desired outcome is to protect existing trees and forests wherever possible and to increase planting efforts to replace any canopy loss and expand the urban forest in underserved areas. Strategy 1. Improve policies and regulations to achieve a better integration of the urban forest within the built environment 1. Consider adopting a tree bylaw to improve protection of trees of importance to the community and require adequate replacements or cash-in-lieu when they must be removed. 2. Consider integrating the canopy cover target and supporting requirements into the OCP, Local Areas Plans, in landscaping requirements in the Zoning Bylaw, Design Criteria Manual, or Form and Character Development Permit Areas, and other strategic policies and initiatives to achieve consistent tree protection and planting and adequate soil volume. 3. Consider updating the Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw to strengthen tree protection and maintenance and improve tree planting quality. 4. Consider enabling the use of delegated minor variances to allow the retention of large and healthy trees during development by varying factors such as setbacks, building height or parking. 5. Clarify responsibilities and workflows to improve inspection and tracking of developer-planted street trees from soil installation to the end of the maintenance period. 6. Update the Environmental Development Permit Areas to integrate a green infrastructure network, specify arborist reporting requirements, and integrate guidelines to avoid impacts to tree within a functional distance. Action 2 recommends updates to land use regulations that would support the retention of sufficient pervious landscape area to grow trees. On properties with limited space, regulations can be written to require both a minimum percentage of pervious area (property A below), and that it be consolidated to provide a landscape area sufficient to plant a tree (property B). Figure 18 Properties A and B have the same amount of pervious area (shown in green); however, A has a narrow pervious edge surrounding the building that is too small for tree planting, and B shows the pervious area consolidated into a single location to support a tree. This illustrates how building setbacks and footprints can be adjusted to better accommodate tree planting. --- page 34 --- 26 City of Langley Strategy 2. Enhance ecosystems to support biodiversity and access to nature 7. Consider developing a natural area management framework to manage and enhance natural areas, such as the Nicomekl floodplain, through restoration planting and management of invasive species. Strategy 3. Grow the urban forest with a focus on tree resilience and equity across neighbourhoods 8. Maintain the City’s current tree population and seek options to expand trees planted in under-served areas with low tree equity scores through annual programs, replacing every tree removed (1:1 replacement), and consider increasing species diversity. 9. Expand the tree network in the public realm and ensure design soil volumes meet industry standards on private property and for new street trees, as supported by actions 2, 3, and 6. 10. Update the recommended tree species list in the Design Criteria Manual and other relevant policies with species information that accounts for future climate suitability to guide tree planting on public and private land and continue to require a diversity of species to reduce vulnerabilities. 11. Consider updating the Design Criteria Manual for boulevard standards to increase soil volume for trees. 12. Continue to trial and monitor various innovative methods to improve tree health. 13. Consider Introducing incentive programs and educational materials to encourage planting and protection on private land, such as a subsidized tree sale or grants for the maintenance of significant trees, and consider a monitoring program to evaluate success. Goal 1 Protect and enhance trees, forests, and soils to connect ecosystems and deliver community benefits Langley City’s Environmentally Sensitive Areas Mapping Study (2016) describes a green infrastructure network as “interconnected network of natural areas and other open spaces that conserves natural ecosystem values and functions, sustains clean air and water, and provides a wide array of benefits to people and wildlife”. The Study recommends that Langley City recognize its environmentally sensitive areas as integral to its green infrastructure network, supported by constructed green infrastructure like green roofs and walls, bioswales, or rain gardens. Microbial inoculants can enhance tree health by introducing beneficial microorganisms that improve soil fertility and structure. These inoculants, such as mycorrhizal fungi and nitrogen-fixing bacteria, form symbiotic relationships with tree roots, increasing nutrient and water uptake while also protecting against soil-borne pathogens. Mycorrhizal fungi, for instance, extend the root system through their hyphal networks, allowing trees to access nutrients and water more efficiently, particularly in poor soils. In recent years, the City has started microbial inoculant trials for newly planted trees and larger stressed trees at selected sites. --- page 35 --- 27 Urban Forest Management Strategy Goal 2 Manage the urban forest more proactively to improve its health and resiliency Trees in the city often face many stressors which can create risks to infrastructure and communities. Urban forest management seeks to minimize tree risks while maximizing benefits to the community. The City of Langley currently manages approximately 16,500 trees on City properties. As Langley City seeks to expand its urban forest, responsibilities and demands to manage the urban forest will grow. Strategies and actions under this goal seek to transition the City towards a more proactive urban forest management program. The desired outcome is to maximize the lifetime of trees across Langley City to maximize urban forest benefits. Strategy 4. Acquire and integrate tree asset information to the City’s asset management system 14. Explore opportunities to inventory all street and planted park trees to include, at a minimum, the species, year planted (where possible), diameter, and condition to inform budgets and service levels. Update the inventory with the pruning cycle. 15. Inventory forest stands to include species composition, forest health concerns, mortality, invasive species detection, encroachment and other factors that can be used to assess the condition of forest stands and prioritize management responses. Update the inventory every five years. 16. Integrate the tree inventory to the City’s asset management system. Strategy 5. Transition to a more proactive urban forest management program 17. Define service levels for young tree maintenance, established tree pruning, and risk management that shift the urban forest maintenance program to proactive management of street and planted park trees. 18. Consider defining service levels for natural areas to help prioritize restoration and other management activities. 19. Consider a City tree policy to define the risk management program and requirements to apply to City operations when removing or working around City trees to meet or exceed private land requirements in the tree bylaw. Strategy 6. Evaluate and maintain sufficient staffing and budget resources to deliver defined urban forest service levels 20. Review and adjust program staffing and budget annually to enable staff to meet service levels as the inventory grows. 21. Evaluate staffing requirements to effectively administer the tree bylaw upon adoption and develop clear operating procedures to delineate departmental responsibilities for the bylaw implementation and enforcement. 22. Explore grant funding opportunities to support tree planting and forest restoration initiatives, such as the Government of Canada’s 2 Billion Trees Program, the Green Municipal Fund – Growing Canada’s Community Canopies, the Tree Canada Granting Programs, or Infrastructure Canada’s Natural Infrastructure Fund. --- page 36 --- 28 City of Langley Urban Forest Asset Management Although more costly during their early and end stages, the benefits of the urban forest far exceed the management costs. Unlike constructed assets like a road or a park bench, trees appreciate in value as they grow and provide their maximum benefits once they reach maturity, usually a few decades after planting. Effective urban forest management ensures that trees reach and maintain healthy maturity, maximizing the return on investment and delaying the need for removal and replacement. Langley City’s current management program already responds to this by prioritizing young tree watering and pruning to facilitate their establishment. By further applying asset management principles to urban forest management, the City can acquire information about the number of assets it manages and their condition (action 15), establish service levels with performance indicators, implement a proactive lifecycle management strategy beyond young tree establishment (action 18), and develop a financial strategy to support these activities (action 21). --- page 37 --- 29 Urban Forest Management Strategy Goal 3 Partner with the community for the stewardship of Langley City’s urban forest With over 64% of canopy cover located on private land, collaborative efforts among the City, community members, stewardship organizations, and local First Nations will continue to play a vital role in protecting and enhancing Langley City’s urban forest. Strategies and actions under this goal seek to recognize the importance of community members and organizations and support their urban forest stewardship. Strategy 7. Explore opportunities to build relationships and work on reconciliation with local First Nations through urban forest management 23. Consider how urban forest initiatives can support the City's initiatives with local First Nations, and consider opportunities to coordinate with First Nations regarding the incorporation of traditional knowledge and practices related to native species, forest and natural areas. Strategy 8. Support and expand initiatives to involve community members, landowners, and organizations in urban forest stewardship 24. Explore opportunities to collaborate with universities and research institutions to increase knowledge of urban forest within the city, for example to monitor the effectiveness of subsidized tree sales (action 13). 25. Explore partnership opportunities with school districts, not-for-profit organizations, and other institutional landowners to increase canopy coverage through tree planting programs. 26. Consider urban forest stewardship programs on City land, for example by encouraging residents to water newly planted trees, and developing online educational resources for developers and property owners on topics such as tree benefits, tree protection, tree care, and tree permit requirements. 27. Support or provide stewardship opportunities for residents which could include watering street trees during dry seasons, invasive species removal and restoration planting 28. Consider supporting public education and outreach initiatives about food forests and fruit trees planting, as part of efforts to improve food security and encourage urban forest stewardship. Youth stewardship events (credit: Green Teams of Canada) --- page 38 --- 30 City of Langley Goal 4 Monitor progress and adapt to urban forest changing circumstances Given the dynamic nature of the urban forest and escalating uncertainties such as climate change, the ability to monitor and adapt to new information or changing conditions will be crucial for effective urban forest management. Strategies and actions under this goal seek to support adaptive management during the implementation of the Urban Forest Management Strategy. Additional performance indicators to report back on Langley City’s urban forest could include: • Number of trees planted, removed, and replaced on public land • Number of trees planted, removed, and replaced on private land • Mortality rates for street trees, park trees, and trees in natural areas • Number of trees planted in low-equity areas • Hectare of natural area restored Strategy 9. Regularly monitor and report on urban forest change 29. Reassess canopy cover every five years using LiDAR or other accurate technologies available. 30. Consider updating the urban forest report card annually and the action plan every five years. 31. Consider creating a monitoring plan to track the UFMS implementation progress, including KPIs for equity, climate resiliency, and stewardship. Strategy 10. Continuously explore options to collect information and adapt practices to changing conditions 32. Trial new technologies to improve tree health and achieve co-benefits with other city initiatives such as stormwater management. 33. Review implementation progress and update the Implementation Plan after 10 years See Appendix 4 for the detailed implementation plan, including detailed action, implementation timeframe, cost, and departmental responsibilities. --- page 39 --- 31 Urban Forest Management Strategy The Implementation Plan The implementation plan outlines a set of initiatives aimed at helping the City of Langley accomplish its urban forest vision and goals. By detailing specific actions, involved departments, implementation timelines, and budgetary needs, the plan provides a comprehensive roadmap for managing the urban forest for the next 15 years. Goal 1: Protect and enhance trees, forests, and soils Timeframe Short: 1-5 years Med: 5-10 years Long: 10-15 years Cost $: Already budgeted/using existing resources $$:$20,000-$100,000 $$$: >$100,000 Lead Department Strategy 1. Improve policies and regulations to achieve a better integration of the urban forest within the built environment 1. Consider adopting a tree bylaw to improve protection of trees of importance to the community and require adequate replacements or cash-in-lieu when they must be removed. Med $$$ Engineering & Parks 2. Consider integrating the canopy cover target and supporting requirements into the OCP, Local Areas Plans, in landscaping requirements in the Zoning Bylaw, Design Criteria Manual, or Form and Character Development Permit Areas, and other strategic policies and initiatives to achieve consistent tree protection and planting and adequate soil volume. Med $$ Planning, Development 3. Consider updating the Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw to strengthen tree protection and maintenance and improve tree planting quality. Short $ Engineering & Parks 4. Consider enabling the use of delegated minor variances to allow the retention of large and healthy trees during development by varying factors such as setbacks, building height or parking. Short $$ Development 5. Clarify responsibilities and workflows to improve inspection and tracking of developer-planted street trees from soil installation to the end of the maintenance period. Short $ Engineering & Parks, Planning 6. Update the Environmental Development Permit Areas to integrate a green infrastructure network, specify arborist reporting requirements, and integrate guidelines to avoid impacts to tree within a functional distance. Med $$ Development Strategy 2. Enhance ecosystems to support biodiversity and access to nature 7. Consider developing a natural area management framework to manage and enhance natural areas such as the Nicomekl floodplain, through restoration planting and management of invasive species etc. Long $$$ Engineering & Parks --- page 40 --- 32 City of Langley Goal 1: Protect and enhance trees, forests, and soils Timeframe Short: 1-5 years Med: 5-10 years Long: 10-15 years Cost $: Already budgeted/using existing resources $$:$20,000-$100,000 $$$: >$100,000 Lead Department Strategy 3. Grow the urban forest with a focus on tree resilience and equity across neighbourhood 8. Maintain the City’s current tree population and seek options to expand trees planted in under-served areas with low tree equity scores through annual programs, replacing every tree removed (1:1 replacement), and consider increasing species diversity Short $$$ Engineering & Parks 9. Expand the tree network in the public realm and ensure design soil volumes meet industry standards on private property and for new street trees, as supported by actions 2, 3, and 6. Long $$ Development 10. Update the recommended tree species list in the Design Criteria Manual and other relevant policies with species information that accounts for future climate suitability to guide tree planting on public and private land and continue to require a diversity of species to reduce vulnerabilities. Short $ Engineering & Parks 11. Consider updating the Design Criteria Manual for boulevard standards to increase soil volume for trees. Short $ Engineering & Parks 12. Continue to trial and monitor various innovative methods to improve tree health, such as microbial inoculant trials conducted by staff. Med $$ Engineering & Parks 13. Consider Introducing incentive programs and educational materials to encourage planting and protection on private land, such as a subsidized tree sale or grants for the maintenance of significant trees, and consider a monitoring program to evaluate success. Short $$ Engineering & Parks --- page 41 --- 33 Urban Forest Management Strategy Goal 2: Manage the urban forest for its health and resiliency Timeframe Short: 1-5 years Med: 5-10 years Long: 10-15 years Cost $: Already budgeted/using existing resources $$:$20,000-$100,000 $$$: >$100,000 Lead Department Strategy 4. Acquire and integrate tree asset information to the City’s asset management system 14. Explore opportunities to inventory all street and planted park trees to include, at a minimum, the species, year planted (where possible), diameter, and condition to inform budgets and service levels. Update the inventory with the pruning cycle (i.e., when visiting trees for scheduled pruning). Med $$$-$$$$ Engineering & Parks 15. Inventory forest stands to include species composition, forest health concerns, mortality, invasive species detection, encroachment and other factors that can be used to assess the condition of forest stands and prioritize management responses. Update the inventory every five years. Med $$$ Engineering & Parks 16. Integrate the tree inventory to the City’s asset management system. Med $$ Engineering & Parks Strategy 5. Transition to a more proactive urban forest management program 17. Define service levels for young tree maintenance, established tree pruning, and risk management that shift the urban forest maintenance program to proactive management of street and planted park trees. Med $$ Engineering & Parks 18. Consider defining service levels for natural areas to help prioritize restoration and other management activities. Med $$ Engineering & Parks 19. Consider a City tree policy to define the risk management program and the requirements to apply to City operations when removing or working around City trees to meet or exceed private land requirements defined in the tree bylaw. Short $$ Engineering & Parks Strategy 6. Evaluate and maintain sufficient staffing and budget resources to deliver defined urban forest service levels 20. Review and adjust program staffing and budget annually to enable staff to meet service levels as the inventory grows. Med $$$-$$$$ Engineering & Parks 21. Evaluate staffing requirements to effectively administer the tree bylaw upon adoption and develop clear operating procedures to delineate departmental responsibilities for the bylaw implementation and enforcement. Short $$$ Engineering & Parks 22. Explore grant funding opportunities to support tree planting and forest restoration initiatives, such as the Government of Canada’s 2 Billion Trees Program, the Green Municipal Fund – Growing Canada’s Community Canopies, the Tree Canada Granting Programs, or Infrastructure Canada’s Natural Infrastructure Fund. Med $$ Engineering & Parks --- page 42 --- 34 City of Langley Goal 3: Support community partnership Timeframe Short: 1-5 years Med: 5-10 years Long: 10-15 years Cost $: Already budgeted/using existing resources $$:$20,000-$100,000 $$$: >$100,000 Lead Department Strategy 7. Create opportunities to build relationships and work on reconciliation with local First Nations through urban forest management 23. Consider how urban forest initiatives can support the City’s relationship building with local First Nations. and consider opportunities to coordinate with First Nations regarding the incorporation of traditional knowledge and practices related to native species, forest and natural areas. Med $$ Engineering & Parks Strategy 8. Support and expand initiatives to involve community members, landowners, and organizations in urban forest stewardship 24. Explore opportunities to collaborate with universities and research institutions to increase knowledge of urban forest within the city, for example to monitor the effectiveness of subsidized tree sales (action 13). Med $$ Engineering & Parks 25. Explore partnership opportunities with school districts, not- for-profit organizations, and other institutional landowners to increase canopy coverage through tree planting programs. Med $ Engineering & Parks 26. Consider urban forest stewardship programs on City land, for example by encouraging residents to water newly planted trees, and developing online educational resources for developers and property owners on topics such as tree benefits, tree protection, tree care, and tree permit requirements. Med $ Engineering & Parks 27. Support or provide stewardship opportunities for residents which could include watering street trees during dry seasons, invasive species removal and restoration planting. Long $ Engineering & Parks 28. Consider supporting public education and outreach initiatives about food forests and fruit trees planting, as part of efforts to improve food security and encourage urban forest stewardship. Med $$-$$$ Engineering & Parks --- page 43 --- 35 Urban Forest Management Strategy Goal 4: Monitor progress and adapt to changing circumstances Timeframe Short: 1-5 years Med: 5-10 years Long: 10-15 years Cost $: Already budgeted/using existing resources $$:$20,000-$100,000 $$$: >$100,000 Lead Department Strategy 9. Regularly monitor and report on urban forest change 29. Reassess canopy cover every five years using LiDAR or other accurate technologies available. Med $$ Engineering & Parks 30. Consider updating the urban forest report card annually and the action plan every five years. Short $$ Engineering & Parks 31. Consider creating a monitoring plan to track the UFMS implementation progress, including KPIs for equity, climate resiliency, and stewardship. Short $$ Engineering & Parks Strategy 10. Continuously explore options to collect information and adapt practices to changing conditions 32. Trial new technologies to improve tree health and achieve co-benefits with other city initiatives such as stormwater management. Long $$-$$$ Engineering & Parks 33. Review implementation progress and update the Implementation Plan after 10 years. Long $$ Engineering & Parks Youth stewardship events (credit: Green Teams of Canada) --- page 44 --- 36 City of Langley 5 Conclusion and Recommendations --- page 45 --- 37 Urban Forest Management Strategy The City of Langley’s Urban Forest Management Strategy marks a pivotal step towards a healthy, diverse, and climate-adapted urban forest in the next 30 years. With a comprehensive vision, a canopy target and supporting goals, this Strategy is a testament to the City’s commitment to mitigating the challenges posed by climate change, urban densification, and evolving community needs. The success of the Strategy hinges on effective implementation. The action plan provides a roadmap for tangible progress covering critical aspects of effective urban forest management, such as climate adaptation, City tree management, and community stewardship. Implementing the Urban Forest Management Strategy is more than a static commitment; it is a dynamic process that will require ongoing monitoring, adaptation, and collaboration. The Strategy includes 10 strategies and 33 actions on implementation and monitoring to support the protection and growth of its urban forest as a thriving asset, contributing to the well-being and vibrancy of Langley City for generations to come. A few ‘quick start’ actions have been identified to initiate implementation of the plan: • Consider integrating the canopy cover target into the OCP, Local Area Plans, Zoning Bylaw, Design Criteria Manual, or Form and Character Development Permit Areas, and other strategic policies and initiatives. • Consider updating the Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw to strengthen tree protection and maintenance and improve tree planting quality. • Clarify responsibilities and workflows to improve inspection and tracking of developer-planted street trees from soil installation to the end of the maintenance period. • Update the recommended tree species list in the Design Criteria Manual and other relevant policies with species information that accounts for future climate suitability to guide tree planting on public and private land and continue to require a diversity of species to reduce vulnerabilities. • Consider a City tree policy to define the risk management program and the requirements to apply to City operations when removing or working around City trees to meet or exceed private land requirements defined in the tree bylaw. • Consider urban forest stewardship programs on City land, for example by encouraging residents to water newly planted trees, and developing online educational resources for developers and property owners on topics such as tree benefits, tree protection, tree care, and tree permit requirements. --- page 46 --- 38 City of Langley Actions that are anticipated to have some of the biggest impacts on Langley City’s canopy, but may require more time and resources to be implemented, include: • Updating policies and regulations to increase tree protection and ensure replacement and growth of the urban forest, including consideration for a tree bylaw (action 1) and updates to development requirements through the Zoning Bylaw or Form and Character Development Permit Areas (action 2) and the Subdivision and Development Servicing (action 3). • Seeking opportunities to transition to a more proactive management of City tree assets to improve tree health and longevity, including exploring having an inventory of urban tree assets (actions 16-17), adjusting staffing and budget as the inventory grows (action 20), as well as considering defining service levels (actions 17-18). • Exploring opportunities to plant more trees across the City, with a focus on under-served areas with a low tree equity score (action 8) and support voluntary planting on private land (action 13). --- page 47 --- 39 Urban Forest Management Strategy References 1 Curran and Gray, (2021). “Green Bylaws Toolkit.” 3rd Edition. Stewardship Centre for BC. https://steward - shipcentrebc.ca/PDF_docs/GreenBylaws/GreenBylawsToolkit_3rdEdition_2021.pdf 2 Municipal Natural Assets Initiative, (2017). “Primer on Natural Asset Management for FCM’s 2018 Sustain - able Communities Conference.” https://mnai.ca/media/2018/01/FCMPrimer_Jan1_2018.pdf 3 The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity. The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity: Ecologi - cal and Economic Foundations. Kumar P, editor. Routledge; 2012. 455 p. 4 Petralli SO Jennifer K Vanos, Andreas Matzarakis, Luciano Massetti, Martina. Urban forestry and microcli - mate. In: Routledge Handbook of Urban Forestry. Routledge; 2017. 5 Berland A, Shiflett SA, Shuster WD, Garmestani AS, Goddard HC, Herrmann DL, et al. The role of trees in urban stormwater management. Landsc Urban Plan. 2017;162:167–77. 6 Roeland S, Moretti M, Amorim JH, Branquinho C, Fares S, Morelli F, et al. Towards an integrative approach to evaluate the environmental ecosystem services provided by urban forest. J For Res. 2019;30(6):1981– 96. 7 Frumkin H. Healthy places: exploring the evidence. Am J Public Health. 2003;93(9):1451–6. 8 Kaplan R. The role of nature in the context of the workplace. Landsc Urban Plan. 1993;26(1–4):193–201. 9 Heaviside C, Macintyre H, Vardoulakis S. The Urban Heat Island: Implications for Health in a Changing Environment. Curr Environ Health Rep. 2017 Sep 1;4(3):296–305. 10 Petralli SO Jennifer K Vanos, Andreas Matzarakis, Luciano Massetti, Martina. Urban forestry and microcli - mate. In: Routledge Handbook of Urban Forestry. Routledge; 2017. 11 Grimm NB, Faeth SH, Golubiewski NE, Redman CL, Wu J, Bai X, et al. Global Change and the Ecology of Cities. Science. 2008 Feb 8;319(5864):756–60. 12 Li D, Bou-Zeid E. Synergistic Interactions between Urban Heat Islands and Heat Waves: The Impact in Cities Is Larger than the Sum of Its Parts. J Appl Meteorol Climatol. 2013 Sep 1;52(9):2051–64. 13 Metro Vancouver. Climate Projections For Metro Vancouver [Internet]. Burnaby, BC: Metro Vancouver; 2016 p. 73. Available from: http://www.metrovancouver.org/services/air-quality/AirQualityPublications/Cli - mateProjectionsForMetroVancouver.pdf 14 Kovats RS, Hajat S. Heat stress and public health: a critical review. Annu Rev Public Health. 2008;29:41– 55. 15 British Columbia Coroners Service. Extreme Heat and Human Mortality: A Review of Heat-Related Deaths in B.C. in Summer 2021 [Internet]. British Columbia: BC Coroners Service; 2022 Jun [cited 2023 Mar 20] p. 53. Available from: https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/birth-adoption-death-marriage-and-divorce/deaths/ coroners-service/death-review-panel/extreme_heat_death_review_panel_report.pdf 16 American Forests. Tree Equity Score [Internet]. American Forests. [cited 2023 Sep 22]. Available from: https://www.americanforests.org/tools-research-reports-and-guides/tree-equity-score/ 17 Metro Vancouver. “2020 Regional Tree Canopy Cover and Impervious Surface in Metro Vancouver.” Metro Vancouver, March 2024. --- page 48 --- 40 City of Langley Appendices --- page 49 --- 41 Urban Forest Management Strategy 1. Urban Forest 101 Why Do We Manage the Urban Forest? Management is essential to preserve the health and longevity of urban forests. Trees, much like other types of City assets, require regular maintenance to maximize the benefits they provide the community and ensure a long service life. Strategic care can prolong a tree’s life, enhancing its ecological, social, and economic contributions. Large, mature trees provide more wildlife habitat, are more effective at cooling, and become beloved landmarks for the community. However, large trees in urban settings also carry potential risks, such as dead or broken branches or lifting sidewalks, that need to be managed for public safety. Proper planning and management can minimize risks, maximize benefits and extend a tree’s life. --- page 50 --- 42 City of Langley Who Manages the Urban Forest? Urban forest stewardship in Langley City requires a collaborative effort, involving the City, public institutions, private entities, and the community. While the City oversees trees on streets, parks, and natural areas, a significant portion of the tree canopy lies on private property, making community involvement essential for comprehensive forest management. Urban forest management requires coordination with, or assistance from, a wide range of partners. A brief overview of some of these partners is provided below: • City of Langley manages trees and forests along streets, in parks, in environmentally sensitive areas, and on other City properties. The City also regulates tree removals and replacement on private lands and in street rights-of-way. • Residents/landowners plant, maintain, and remove trees on their properties. They also benefit from, advocate for, and participate in the stewardship of trees and forests on public lands through committees, community organizations, and as individuals. • First Nations groups , particularly the ʷɑ:n ̓ ƛ ̓ ən ̓ (Kwantlen), Máthxwi (Matsqui), q ̓ ic ̓ əy ̓ (Katzie) and e’mya’me (Semiahmoo) First Nations, have a long-standing but disrupted relationship with the land and trees in their unceded territories. As part of the journey towards reconciliation, it is important for the City, local organizations, and residents to understand the historical and ongoing impacts of colonial settlement and their traditional knowledge and practices for more equitable, inclusive, and sustainable practices. • NGOs , such as the Langley Environmental Partnership Society and Langley City Parks Foundation, offer educational and stewardship opportunities to local communities and individuals and support greening and ecological restoration in Langley City. • BC Hydro and Fortis plant, prune, and remove trees near utility lines. • Private industry arborists and landscape companies provide tree- related professional services such as tree planting, pruning and risk assessment, to improve tree health and minimize tree hazards. • Metro Vancouver manages forests and vegetation in regional parks. It also provides regional-level urban forestry and green infrastructure resources and guidance for member jurisdictions, and identifies, protects, and manages lands with unique natural biodiversity. • Province of British Columbia regulates watercourses and their riparian areas and the Agricultural Land Reserve. The Province also monitors forest health and is responsible for native forest climate change adaptation strategies. • Government of Canada provides funding for climate adaptation and mitigation, and regulates invasive pests, plants and diseases. --- page 51 --- 43 Urban Forest Management Strategy 2. Policies and regulations that guide urban forestry Enabling legislation The Local Government Act and the Community Charter give the City of Langley power to introduce regulations and protection requirements for the urban forest within its boundary. Higher level strategies and plans The Official Community Plan (OCP) includes a vision that acknowledges the importance of nature in tackling climate change issues, restoring ecological health, and making people-friendly streets and great public places that cater to all users. The urban forest is addressed in 19 policy statements, including promoting park dedication and acquisition for new development, retention of mature trees, enhancement of trail and green space connectivity, and integration of natural assets in the current asset management program. The OCP also establishes Development Permit Areas (DPAs) for enhanced protection of the Environmentally Sensitive Areas (ESAs) (e.g., restricting development in ESAs with moderate to high values), and regulated development activities within the DPAs (e.g., imposing stricter requirements on DP applications and stricter form and character requirements). The Sustainability Framework is a guiding document that outlines the City’s sustainability commitment and goals. The urban forest and trees are recognized in four focus areas and goals: 1) Arts, culture, and heritage, 2) Health, safety, and well-being, 3) Natural areas, parks, and recreation, and 4) Water. The Parks, Recreation, and Culture (PRC) Master Plan (2022 draft) aims to strategically guide and manage the direction of parks, recreation, and culture for the next 10 years. The plan specifies park planning and management directions, such as land acquisition in developing areas to reach a minimum of 0.6 hectare park size and improve park access for residents. The Nature Trails Network Plan is a long-term strategy for enhancing the City’s trail system. It offers recommendations and guidelines supportive of retaining existing mature trees and vegetation, prioritizing native species in natural areas, and restoring disturbed areas. Lastly, developing an Urban Forest Management Strategy was specified in City-level documents such as the Interim Strategic Plan 2021-2022 and Strategic Plan 2017-2021 . --- page 52 --- 44 City of Langley Bylaws, policies, and guidelines Langley City regulates its urban forest through several bylaws, policies, and guidelines. On private lands, the management of trees relies on a combination of Zoning Bylaw, Development Permit Area (DPA) Guidelines, and Floodplain Elevation Bylaw. The Zoning Bylaw specifies landscaping requirements, including the provision of buffers, screens, and amenity space in areas zoned for different uses. The DPA Guidelines define specific requirements for tree planting in designated areas, such as commercial parking spaces and plazas. In Environmentally Sensitive Areas (ESAs), the ESA DPA Guidelines and Floodplain Elevation Bylaw work together to protect trees by limiting development and enforcing protection and setback requirements. Trees on City-owned land, such as parks and roads, are subject to the Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw, Parks and Public Facility Regulation Bylaw, and Design Criteria Manual. The Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw specifies requirements on street tree planting, park space conveyance and the warranty of developer-planted trees. The Parks and Public Facility Regulation Bylaw protects park trees from damage and unauthorized removal. For boulevard trees, the Design Criteria Manual provides detailed planting specifications, such as soil volume, species and spacing. --- page 53 --- Regulations of trees in the City of Langley Public Private KEY No formally adopted policy guides tree planting in forested and landscaped parks. The OCP enables use of density bonusing to provide parks and open space. The Parks and Public Facility Regulation Bylaw forbids any action that damages, remove trees, including deposit any waste, offensive materials or other substance of any kind into or upon any trees. The park conveyance required by the Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw may need to be kept in a natural state and follow specific protection measures such as fencing. Maintaining trees Protecting and replacing trees Planting new trees Urban Forest Management Theme Trees in forested and landscaped parks City-owned street trees Private yard trees Private trees in riparian and other ESAs The Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw requires boulevard tree planting for areas with OCP land use designations as a minimum service requirement. Boulevard planting should follow the City’s Design Criteria Manual , which provides detailed requirements on soil volume, tree species and sizes, spacing, planting for boulevard tree and vegetation. The Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw requires developers to maintain newly planted City trees period of 1 year and specifies boulevard maintenance requirements (e.g., weed control and irrigation). The Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw requires an offsite tree protection plan for areas with OCP land use designations as a minimum service requirement. During construction, the Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw requires tree protection measures for offsite trees. The Zoning Bylaw defines landscaping requirements to screen lots of different uses, increase pervious areas, provide outdoor greenspace or urban agricultural amenity areas. The Form and Character DPA Guidelines require tree planting in commercial parking lots, in plazas and squares, or in interior pathways. Other DPA Guidelines require or encourage tree planting for screening, traffic calming and decorative purposes. No formally adopted policy guides the maintenance of trees in private yards. No formally adopted policy guides the maintenance of trees in riparian and other ESAs. No formally adopted policy guides the protection and replacement of trees in private yards outside of the ESAs and protected riparian areas. No formally adopted policy guides tree planting in riparian and other ESAs. The Environmentally Sensitive Area DPA Guidelines introduces setback and information requirements to protect the ESAs and discourages development close to mature and large tree stands. The Floodplain Elevation Bylaw specifies setback requirements for development in floodplain of Nicomekl River and other watercourses. The Subdivision and Development Servicing Bylaw may require 5% parkland conveyance or cash-in-lieu for large subdivisions that create three or more new lots. No other formally adopted policy guides tree planting in forested landscaped parks. --- page 54 --- 46 City of Langley Measuring tree canopy Light detection and ranging (LiDAR) is a remote sensing technology that uses laser light to measure distance and create a detailed, 3D representation of the Earth’s surface and its features. How LiDAR works : LiDAR data is usually acquired from a plane or drone that emits laser pulses vertically toward the ground. The technology measures distance to the ground based on the time required for the laser light to rebound on the surface to create a 3D point cloud of the ground, trees, and buildings. For this Strategy, the project team used aerial imagery in combination with LiDAR to create a high resolution tree canopy map, then used a technique called individual tree detection to isolate individual trees. This method provides information about tree heights and counts, allowing further analysis of forest structure and categorization. Individual tree detection provides an coarse estimate of the count of overstory trees. Tree counts presented in the Strategy are very approximate and accuracy would be improved with a comprehensive tree inventory. 3. The State of the Urban Forest --- page 55 --- 47 Urban Forest Management Strategy Canopy Cover Change Canopy cover changes as trees grow, decline, or get removed due to natural causes or human activities. Tracking these shifts over time can shed light on the drivers of change that the Strategy can address. For example, identifying locations where the tree canopy is declining can inform actions to reverse trends. Conversely, increases in canopy cover can indicate successful management practices or the natural growth of the urban forest. Langley City’s canopy cover change was tracked for 2010, 2016 and 2021 using two types of datasets: combined LiDAR and aerial imagery, and a statistical tool called i-Tree Canopy 1 . The datasets provide an estimate of citywide canopy cover for each of the three years ( Figure A1 ), and datasets from 2016 and 2021 allow fine-scale spatial comparisons of changes across the City ( Figure A2 ). Figure A1 reveals a decline in Langley City’s canopy cover, dropping from 20% in 2010 to 17% in 2021. Detailed canopy mapping for 2016 and 2021 provides insights as to where and why those changes took place. It is important to note that although the mapping, which uses mixed datasets of LiDAR and aerial imageries, indicates a 1% canopy reduction from 2016 to 2021, seasonal differences in when the LiDAR was flown in each year mean that the decline may be overstated (see limitations below). Even accounting for seasonal differences in the measurements, there are areas of notable canopy change. Pronounced canopy losses, illustrated in red in Figure A2 , span the City but are more concentrated in its western and southwestern regions. Canopy growth in the City is attributed to the natural maturation and expansion of trees over time. Prominent areas with increased canopy cover are indicated by green circles in Figure A2 . 1 i-Tree Canopy is a tool developed by the USDA Forest Service that helps users estimate land cover, including tree canopy cover using aerial imagery. Figure A1 Canopy cover in Langley City from 2010 to 2021 Data Limitations Tracking changes in canopy cover requires datasets to be comparable to avoid capturing trends that are due to data limitations rather than real change. One common issue with comparing canopy data extracted from LiDAR and aerial imagery is seasonality; when data is captured while deciduous trees don’t have leaves, the data tends to underestimate the extent of canopy they provide because finer branches at the edge of canopy might not be captured by the data. In Langley City, the 2021 canopy data combines leaf-off LiDAR data with leaf-on aerial imagery to minimize the underestimate. The seasonality of the data means that 2021 canopy cover might underestimate slightly the growth of deciduous trees as compared to the 2016 data. The 2010 data uses a tool based on aerial imagery that provides a good citywide comparison, but unlike the data extracted from combined LiDAR and imagery data, does not allow us to identify specific areas of loss and gain within the city. --- page 56 --- 48 City of Langley Figure A2 Map of canopy change from 2016 to 2021 (see examples A-D of canopy change on the following pages) --- page 57 --- 49 Urban Forest Management Strategy A Example of tree loss in Brydon Park for the construction of open park spaces and additional development: B Example of tree loss for the development of low rise residential building at 55a Ave and Brydon Crescent: --- page 58 --- 50 City of Langley C Example of street tree loss in the historic downtown core: D Example of tree loss in Hunter Park for construction of open park spaces: --- page 59 --- 51 Urban Forest Management Strategy By land use The majority of the canopy loss was recorded in areas for suburban and low-rise residential OCP land uses, representing 40% and 31% of the total canopy change, respectively ( Figure A3 ). The pronounced loss in low-rise residential and possibly suburban regions can be attributed to increased redevelopment activities within these areas. In contrast, parks and open spaces defied this trend, registering the highest canopy gain at 8%. Other land uses experienced minimal changes in their canopy cover. Figure A3 Canopy cover, land area and canopy change from 2016 to 2021 summarized by land use Figure A4 Official Community Plan land use designations --- page 60 --- 52 City of Langley Impermeability and tree planting Cities tend to become increasingly impermeable as urbanization leads to soil being covered by paved surfaces like asphalt or cement and buildings. Areas with a high impervious surface cover see more surface water runoff when water can no longer infiltrate the ground, leading to higher flooding risks and declining water quality and soil moisture. Impervious surfaces also emit more heat and create what is known as the urban heat island effect (see page 53 ). Highly impermeable areas in Langley City are concentrated north of the Nicomekl River and correspond to areas with some of the lowest tree canopy cover in the City ( Figure A5 ). The high prevalence of impermeable surfaces makes tree planting more challenging because there are usually fewer opportunities for trees to access sufficient soil volume and water. Retrofitting space for trees to grow in highly impermeable areas is possible but more costly than where opportunities to plant trees in existing soil are available. An example of a very impervious surface An example of a very pervious surface Figure A5 Map of pervious and impervious areas in the City --- page 61 --- 53 Urban Forest Management Strategy Urban heat and the urban forest Cities are warmer than surrounding rural areas. This is a phenomenon known as the urban heat island effect 9 . One of the main causes of the urban heat island effect is urbanization. Buildings, roads, and paved surfaces in urban areas absorb solar radiation during the day and slowly release it in the evening. Hard surfaces holding heat leads to higher temperatures in the City, both day and night. Hard surfaces also reduce space for trees and vegetation that would help cool the surroundings through shade and evapotranspiration 10 , 11 . Urban heat islands are made more dangerous by the increasing frequency of extreme heat events that raise temperatures to levels that threaten human health 12 , 13 . Extreme heat can cause heat exhaustion and heat stroke, especially for vulnerable groups like the elderly and individuals with pre-existing health conditions 14 . A real-world example that underscores the severe human health impacts of extreme heat is the 2021 heat dome event in British Columbia, Canada. This unprecedented event led to temperatures soaring well above the average, reaching records of up to 49.6°C. The intense, sustained heat resulted in a catastrophic increase in sudden deaths, with the provincial Coroners Service reporting nearly 600 more deaths than the five-year average for the same time period 15 . Figure A6 shows the land surface temperature in the City of Langley on June 30, 2021, during the heat dome. The temperature varied by over 10°C, with the hottest spot concentrated in the most impervious areas while the coolest spots were found in areas that have a high pervious and tree canopy cover. Figure A6 Land surface temperature derived from satellite image taken on June 30, 2021 --- page 62 --- 54 City of Langley Urban Forest Structure Within Langley City’s urban forest, trees grow in a variety of contexts. These contexts contribute to the structure of the urban forest, which can be thought of as the size, species, age, and arrangement of trees and how it varies. While trees of different sizes and ages have their role in a healthy urban forest ecosystem, large mature trees provide the greatest benefits to the community and the environment. For this reason, urban forest management should strive to create the conditions for large trees to thrive wherever possible. The analysis of Langley City’s tree canopy involved a cutting-edge single tree detection technique that provides tree count, height and type (coniferous vs. deciduous) information of every individually segmented tree canopy (each means one tree). The information allows a better understanding of the structure of the urban forest. Most trees in Langley City (79%) are under 20 meters in height, suggesting a relatively young urban forest in the City. These trees collectively contribute to 55% of the overall canopy in the City. In contrast, taller and more mature trees account for a small proportion of the urban forest population, with trees over 30 meters tall representing only 7%. Nevertheless, these mature trees contribute to 16% of the total tree canopy cover. To gain a better understanding of which areas rely on small or young trees for their canopy cover and which areas have a higher number of large and mature trees, it is helpful to explore the relationships among tree count, canopy area, and tree height in different parts of the City. Figure A8 shows the urban forest structure information in environmentally sensitive areas (ESAs, including forested natural areas on both public and private lands) and the urban areas (i.e., areas outside of the ESAs). Figure A7 City-wide tree count and canopy area by height class --- page 63 --- 55 Urban Forest Management Strategy In urban areas, trees tend to be smaller and younger, with 56% of trees being under 10 meters tall. Among all height classes, trees of 10-20 meters tall provide the most canopy cover, representing 36% of the total canopy cover in urban areas. Langley City’s natural areas have a very different structure ( Figure A8 ). Within mapped ESAs, there is a more even distribution of small to large trees. Trees taller than 30 metres, likely the oldest in the population, contribute most significantly to the canopy in natural areas, at 20%. Figure A8 Tree count and canopy area by height class in urban areas (non-ESA area; top) and ESA area (bottom) --- page 64 --- 56 City of Langley Tree type The majority of Langley City’s urban forest is deciduous, making up 61% of the total canopy cover ( Figure A9 ). Among these deciduous trees, 57% are located on private land, while the remaining 43% are distributed along streets, in parks, and other publicly managed areas. Coniferous trees, on the other hand, are more commonly found on private properties (especially in the southern section of the City), accounting for 79% of the citywide coniferous tree canopy cover. Figure A9 Distribution of deciduous and coniferous trees in Langley City, based on 2021 canopy data --- page 65 --- 57 Urban Forest Management Strategy Tallest trees Although the most common native trees in Langley City can reach heights of well over 30 metres, only 7% of trees reach exceed this threshold, with 1% of trees being over 40 meters tall. Most tall trees are found in forested natural areas, primarily in upland and riparian forests where conifers dominate. The tallest tree, standing at 53 meters in 2021, is a grand fir on the banks of the Nicomekl River, as illustrated in Figure A10 . Figure A10 Tall trees in Langley City --- page 66 --- 58 City of Langley Forested Natural Areas About 30% of Langley City’s trees grow in forested natural areas. While most of the trees in natural areas are native species, many natural areas contain non-native tree species as well, some of which may be naturalizing or invasive. Natural areas in Langley City are fragmented by urban development, which makes them more vulnerable to disturbance and ecological change. Forested natural areas in Langley City can be placed in three main groups: upland forests, lowland forests, and riparian/ravine forests. Consulting staff conducted field assessments to determine the characteristics of the City’s forested natural areas. See Figure A11 for the locations of field assessments. Figure A11 Locations of field assessments in the summer of 2023 --- page 67 --- 59 Urban Forest Management Strategy Upland forests Upland forests are often composed of coniferous tree species like Douglas-fir and western redcedar, with other species like western hemlock and grand fir seen occasionally. These forests are the legacy of logging and land clearing that occurred in the Fraser Valley between 1858 and the mid-1950s, as well as early fires that were often set for land clearing purposes. When approaching maturity, these forests are often dense and dark enough to exclude regenerating young trees. However, both younger and older upland forests can have vibrant communities of understorey shrubs and plants like salal, Oregon-grape, red huckleberry, sword fern, and regenerating trees. Increasing drought is an important threat to these forests, which can have deep water tables during the summer months. Western hemlock and western redcedar are particularly vulnerable to drier soils. When disturbed, such as so-called old-field sites, uplands also support forests of short-lived deciduous species like red alder and black cottonwood. --- page 68 --- 60 City of Langley Lowland forests Lowland forests are mainly composed of fast-growing deciduous species today, although in the past they would have included more coniferous trees. Forests that grow in the floodplain of the Nicomekl River must tolerate frequent flooding and waterlogged soil. Red alder and black cottonwood are common tree species, sometimes forming closed canopy forests that sit just above the water table. The lowest and wettest sites are often occupied by shrub communities with scattered willow trees. Conifers tolerant of wet soils are found in these forests, like Sitka spruce, grand fir, and western redcedar, while shore pine is sometimes found in association with peat soils or small bogs. These forests can be particularly vulnerable to invasion by invasive plant species, which are often transported by water, animals, and humans along the corridor. Illegal dumping and water pollution are other important issues. Short-lived deciduous trees are often associated with elevated hazards to trails and park infrastructure because of their rapid decay profile. --- page 69 --- 61 Urban Forest Management Strategy Riparian/ravine forests Riparian forests occupy the many ravines that flow from uplands towards the Nicomekl River in Langley City. They often contain mixtures of deciduous and coniferous species, and because of their unique terrain can contain trees both tolerant and intolerant of flooding. Any of Langley City’s native tree species can occur here. Forest canopies in riparian areas are often patchy, with occasional gaps between large trees, which allows rich understorey plant communities to develop. Because riparian areas were often spared from land clearing fires or logging, many of Langley City’s oldest, largest trees are found in them. Riparian areas are important connections for wildlife between upland and lowland areas, and provide important recreation and greenspace in Langley City’s residential areas. They can be impacted by invasive species issues, illegal dumping and camping, erosion from inadequate or broken water control structures, and soil compaction from unauthorized trails. --- page 70 --- 62 City of Langley Significant Stands There are over 51 ha of forest stands in the City of Langley, contributing to 30% of its citywide canopy cover ( Figure A12 ). These forests support ecosystems for a diverse range of wildlife, with 80% of the forests offering moderately high to high environmentally sensitive area value, a value to measure the significance of ESAs according to the City’s Environmentally Sensitive Areas Mapping Study in 2015 ( Figure A13 ). Figure A12 Forest stands of different levels of ESA value --- page 71 --- 63 Urban Forest Management Strategy Figure A13 ESA values of different forest stands in Langley City Environmentally Sensitive Area Mapping Study (2016) The City of Langley initiated an Environmentally Sensitive Area (ESA) Mapping Study in 2015, an update from the earlier planning based on data from 1997 and 2002. This project, guided by the Official Community Plan (2005) and Sustainability Framework (2010), emphasizes the protection of ESAs and the creation of an ecological network for biodiversity and recreation. The study identified various natural features such as riparian areas, forest patches, and ecological corridors ( Figure A14 ), assessed their ecological value ( Figure A15 ), and provided 38 prioritized management recommendations. These recommendations span planning, conservation of species, addressing climate change, and community involvement. The project also established a monitoring framework to track ecological health and management performance over time, ensuring Langley’s continued commitment to environmental preservation and a livable community. --- page 72 --- 64 City of Langley Figure A14 Identified natural areas and features from the ESA Mapping Study 2016 --- page 73 --- 65 Urban Forest Management Strategy 200 St 208 St 203 St 53 Ave Fraser Hwy 196 St 48 Ave 62 Ave 56 Ave Grade Cres Logan Ave 201 A St 207 St 46 Ave 50 Ave 49 Ave 204 St 44 Ave Glover Rd 209 St 55 A Ave 46 A Ave 51 B Ave 206 St 205 A St Douglas Cres 198 St Langley Bypass Duncan Way Production Way 207 A St Industrial Ave 49 A Ave Michaud Cres 198 C St 52 Ave 60 Ave 197 A St 209 A St Mufford Cres 53 A Ave 205 St 198 St 56 Ave 44 Ave 207 St 206 St 208 St 204 St 56 Ave 196 St 62 Ave 50 Ave Fraser Hwy 48 Ave 55 A Ave 206 St 0 250 500 125 Metres Drawn By: D. Lishman and C. Lefrancois Date: Oct. 29, 2015 Project: Langley ESA Mapping Study Environmentally Sensitive Areas Client: City of Langley Ortho Year: 2014 Legend City of Langley Boundary Watercourses Railway Sensitive Ecosystem Inventory (Metro Vancouver) Values Low Moderately Low Moderate Moderately High High ² Figure A15 ESA value map based on four aspects: ecosystem rarity, species of conservation concern, floodplain mapping, and watercourse and riparian --- page 74 --- 66 City of Langley Tree Equity A critical aspect of urban forest planning and management is equity, specifically regarding how people access and enjoy the benefits provided by the urban forest. It is noteworthy that Langley City’s urban forest is not equitably distributed across the City. To gain a more thorough understanding of the urban forest distribution and whether it is situated where it is most needed, a quantitative method known as the Tree Equity Score (TES) developed by American Forests was used 16 . The TES gauges the equitable distribution of a city’s urban forest, considering a combination of factors such as climate, income, and employment ( Table A1 ). The scores serve as a tool for cities to discern areas that should be prioritized for improvement in tree equity. A lower TES suggests a more pronounced gap in tree canopy coverage in priority areas, thereby indicating a higher priority for increasing tree canopy. Indicator Metric Description Climate Temperature Average land surface temperature, as measured from remote sensing data Income People in poverty Percentage of people living on income 200% below the federally-designated poverty line (<$40,000 per year) Age Dependency ratio Ratio of seniors (age 65+) and children (0-14 years old) to working age adults (15-64) Race People of colour Percentage of people belong to visible minority group as defined by the Employment Equity Act and, if so, the visible minority group to which the person belongs to. Employment Unemployment Rate Percentage of people who do not have a job, but are available and looking for one Table A1 Priority index indicators used in calculating TES by census dissemination area --- page 75 --- 61 Figure A16 Priority index map based on climate, income, race, age, and employment factors --- page 76 --- 68 Urban Forest Management Strategy Figure A17 Tree equity score by census dissemination area As illustrated in Figure A17 , while some areas have the highest possible TES (100 out of 100), many areas, especially in the northern part of the City and around the downtown area, have relatively low TES (lowest at 54). These findings suggest that the urban forest in these areas may not be adequately serving its residents and might require targeted planning interventions to promote equitable distribution. --- page 77 --- 69 Urban Forest Management Strategy 4. Engagement Summaries --- page 78 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary i City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy Phase 1 Engagement Summary September 2023 Table of C ont ents 1.0 SCOPE OF THE ENGAGEMENT ................................ ................................ ................................ ... 1 1.1 Objectives for public engagement ................................ ................................ ................................ ............... 1 1.2 Engagement activities ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ .. 2 1.3 Communication tactics used ................................ ................................ ................................ ........................ 3 2.0 WHO WE HEARD FROM ................................ ................................ ................................ ............ 4 2.1 Survey demographics ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ... 4 3.0 WHAT WE HEARD ................................ ................................ ................................ ..................... 5 3.1 Understanding how the urban forest is valued and the vision for 2050 ................................ ..................... 5 3.2 Important urban forest places ................................ ................................ ................................ ..................... 7 3.3 The urban forest on your street ................................ ................................ ................................ ................... 9 3.4 Priorities for urban forest management ................................ ................................ ................................ .... 10 3.5 Urban forest service levels ................................ ................................ ................................ ......................... 15 3.6 Community stewardship ................................ ................................ ................................ ............................ 17 4.0 SYNTHESIS OF FEEDBACK ................................ ................................ ................................ ........ 20 5.0 NEXT STEPS ................................ ................................ ................................ ............................. 23 APPENDIX 1 SAMPLE COMMUNICATION AND PROMOTION MATERIALS ................................ ..... 23 --- page 79 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 1 1.0 Scope of the Engagement The City of Langley is developing an Urban Forest Management Strategy (UFMS) to manage and grow the urban forest over the next 30 years (to 2050) . Langley’s urban forest faces complex challenges from increasing development and climate change impacts . The UFMS will establish a community - supported vision and goals, as well as supporting implementation recommendations, to effectively address the current challenges confronting Langley’s urban forest and to sustain a healthy and resilient urban forest . Two phases of public engagement are planned to inform the UFMS. The initial phase of public engagement occurred in June and July 2023. The engagement aimed to gather community’s inputs on a long - term strategic urban forestry vision and supporting goals to guide the protection and management of the urban forest . The second phase of engagement is planned for the f all of 2023 and will seek opinions on the draft strategy. 1.1 Objectives for public engagement Objectives for public engagement are: • To inform the public about o The status of our urban forest o The role of our urban forest in the community, including the unique environmental, economic, and social value of Langley ’s urban forest o The opportunities and challenges for urban forest management, particularly due to ongoing development and climate change • To consult the community to: o Identify and acknowledge their concerns and aspirations for the City’s urban forest o Develop a long - term vision and goals for the strategy that capture the community’s perspective on the City’s urban forest • To obtain feedback on the draft UFMS • To build community awareness, support, and advocacy for our urban forest and the updated UFMS --- page 80 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 2 1.2 Engagement a ctivities The public was invited to provide input through a 20 - minute online survey 1 , a mapping tool hosted on the project page , and a pop - up booth at the Community Day Festival in June 2023. An online open house scheduled for June 27, 2023, was cancelled due to lack of attendance. The project team presented to the Environmental Sustainability Committee in July 2023 and sought input from committee members . Details on engagement opportunities for Phase 1 are outlined in Table 1. Table 1 . Summary of engagement opportunities in Phase 1 Engagement Date Engagement Activity Participants June 10, 2023 Booth at Community Day Festival Approx. 30 visitors June 8 to July 19, 2023 Survey 19 6 respondents June 8 to July 19, 2023 Mapping tool: Share locations that you value or want to improve 5 8 submissions July 13, 2023 P resentation to the City ’s Environmental Sustainability Committee 10 committee members Urban Forest Management Strategy booth at the Community Day Festival 1 Paper copies of the survey were made available upon request --- page 81 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 3 1.3 Communication tactics used Information on engagement opportunities was communicated via several available online platforms to reach as many people as possible . Promotional materials used are in the appendix . The p latforms used included : • Dedicated UFMS project page , news and event items, and homepage slider on the City’s website. • City of Langley social media accounts: Facebook, Instagram, Twitter . • Events to links added in the City’s e Newsletter --- page 82 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 4 2.0 Who we heard from We have engaged more than 2 05 people in Phase 1 Engagement, including 196 survey respondents, 10 Environmental Sustainability Committee members and people who visited the pop - up booth and/or who used the mapping tool. 2.1 Survey demographics Of the 19 6 survey respondents: ➢ 77 % reside in the City of Langley ➢ 75 % are homeowners, 16 % renters ➢ Most respondents live in Nicomekl (24%) and Simonds (19%) ( Figure 1 ) ➢ 6 2 % are 35 - 64 years old ( Figure 2 ) ➢ 52% found out about this survey through social media, and 19% through the City’s newsletter Figure 1 . Where survey respondents reside (total respondents =13 4 ) Figure 2 . Age of survey respondents (total respondents = 155) 15% 7% 11% 13% 13% 19% 25% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% I don’t know Alice Brown Blacklock Uplands Douglas Simonds Nicomekl % of Respondents 1% 3% 10% 20% 18% 24% 12% 6% 6% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 0-19 20-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65-74 75+ Prefer not to answer % of Respondents Age --- page 83 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 5 3.0 What We Heard Results from the first phase of public engagement are summarized in this section and structured around the following engagement topics : • Understanding how the urban forest is valued and vision for 2050 • Important urban forest places • Preference for street trees (size and distribution) • Priorities for urban forest management on City - owned land and private land • Satisfaction with and preferred urban forest service levels • Community stewardship of the urban forest 3.1 Understanding how the urban forest is valued and the vision for 2050 Survey respondents were asked to rank the benefits they valued in an urban forest ( Figure 3 ). Respondents ranked ecological ( e.g., providing habitat and food for native plants and animals), environmental services (e.g., rainwater management, air purification, wind protection) and climate change resilience ( e.g., shad ing streets and buildings, carbon storage) as the most important urban forest benefits to them and their community. Survey respondents ranked cultural, economic, and health and social benefits as lower importance. Figure 3 . Respondents ranking of urban forest benefits (total respondents = 175) Members of the Environmental Sustainability Committee (the Committee for short hereafter) were invited to share their current impressions of Langley City’s urban forest. They used words such as “ natural ”, “ protecting ”, “ well - being ”, and “ heritage ” to describe the current values they appreciate 2% 2% 11% 23% 26% 37% 2% 2% 6% 30% 29% 30% 7% 2% 11% 31% 29% 20% 38% 5% 31% 10% 7% 9% 38% 17% 35% 4% 4% 2% 13% 73% 6% 1% 6% 2% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Cultural interest, e.g., old, unique or culturally important trees, beautification, spiritual significance/meaning Economic, e.g., increased property values, tourism, food production Health and social, e.g., improved mental health; places to meet people, recreate, and exercise Environmental services, e.g., rainwater management, air purification, wind protection Climate change resilience, e.g., shade and cooling of streets and buildings, flood protection, role in carbon cycle and… Ecological, e.g., habitat and food for native (local) plants and animals 1 - Most important 2 3 4 5 6 - Least important --- page 84 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 6 about the urban forest. However, there were also expressions of concern. Terms like “ lacking ”, “ lost ”, and “ too many trees clear cut ” suggest that Committee members would like Langley City to strengthen it s urban forest protection measures . Figure 4 . Presentation participants' description of Langley City's urban forest from 5 Committee members Survey r espondents were asked to imagine what they would like Langley’s urban forest to look like in 205 0. All respondents wanted more trees in the city . Their responses were analyzed by counting the frequency of specific key terms ( Figure 5 ). The term s “ tree ” (107 mentions), “ green ” (39 mentions), “ forest ” (27 mentions), “ park ” (35 mentions), and “ canopy ” (12 mentions) were most used to describe respondents’ desire for more green space and “ large [r]” (31 mentions) tree s and tree canopy. In particular, people wanted more green spaces for “ shade ” and “ cool [ing]” (33 mentions) for “ walk [ing]” (10 mentions), “ biodiversity ” and “ wildlife ” habitat (12 mentions). Participants described their ideal urban forests “ health [ y ] ” (22 mentions), diverse tree species (16 mentions of “ mix ”/ “ diverse ”/ “ balanced ” ) “ native ” (14 mentions), and “ lush ” (12 mentions) . Figure 5 . Word cloud showing the most common words used by respondents to describe their vision of the urban forest by 2050 (total respondents = 131 ) --- page 85 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 7 3.2 Important urban forest places Community members used the mapping tool , through the online platform or in - person during the Community Day festival , to identify important urban forest places that they value or need improvement. A total of 60 locations were identified , i ncluding 1 6 ( 27 %) places of value and 44 (7 3 %) places needing improvements. Most locations were submitted for a rea s in and around d owntown Langley City ( 43 %, 2 6 locations), primarily for places needing improvements and with only one place of value. Places of value Across the entire City, 75 % of valued places were in parks or along trails (1 2 locations) and were mostly found along the Nicomekl River District and trails leading there. The other 4 submissions were in unprotected greenspace or natural areas, streetscapes, and private yards. Value locations are summarized in Figure 6 . The most common reasons respondents valued locations were strong ties to a specific park, greenspace, or otherwise large tree s . Several people indicated that they valued overall greenness or canopy cover rather than a single, specific tree. Other reasons places were valued included seeing/supporting wildlife, opportunities for recreation, and general beauty and aesthetic value. Figure 6 . Places of value identified in urban forest using the online mapping tool between June – July 2023 ( 1 6 submissions ) “ This is a true beauty in Langley that deserves to be preserved & possibly made bigger . ” - Respondent on valuing the point in between Grade Crescent and 50 Avenue. --- page 86 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 8 Places needing improvement Urban forest places needing improvement are summarized in Figure 7 . Out of the total 44 submissions, most submitted places were in and around Downtown Langley (25 location; 57 % of submissions ). P eople suggested more tree planting along residential streets and major roads such as where the Fraser highway crosses Downtown Langley and along Douglas Cres cent , 203 Street, and 204 Street ( 30 locations, 68 % of submissions) . Other places submitted for improvement were found in the parks (2 5 %; 11 locations) that are mostly lawn, i.e., Portage Park, Portage Playground, and Conder Park. Participants recommended adding more tree s to th ose location s , having a greater diversity of plants an d trees, expanding the trail systems and greenways, protecting wildlife habitats, and having better dog recreation amenities. Figure 7 . Place needing improvement identified in urban forest using the online mapping tool in June – July 2023 ( 44 submissions ) --- page 87 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 9 3.3 The u rban f orest on your s treet Survey r espondents were asked to identify the photo that most resembled their street and a preference for what they would like their street to resemble ( Figure 8 ). Most respondents currently live on a street resembling O ption D – mixed spacing and species, medium - sized trees (25%), O ption A – Few or no trees (1 8 %), and Option F – Mixed spacing and species, large trees ( 16% ) . Only 26% of respondents live on a street with large trees present ( o ption E or F ) : 16 % o f respondents live on a street with mixed spacing and species, large trees (Option F) and 10 % of respondents live on a street with regularly spaced, large trees (Option E) . When asked which street they would prefer to live on, 60% of respondents indicated a preference to live on a street with large trees ( o ptions E or F ). Only 2% of respondents would like to live on a street with regularly spaced small trees (Option B) , and no respondents want to live by a street with few or no trees (Option A) . A. Few or no trees B. Regularly spaced small trees C. Regularly spaced, medium - sized trees D. Mixed spacing and species (different types of trees), medium sized trees --- page 88 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 10 E. Regularly spaced, large trees F. Mixed spacing and species (different types of trees) , large trees Figure 8 . Types of street tree planting presented to survey respondents (total respondents = 168 ) 3.4 Priorities for u rban f orest m anagement Survey respondents were asked to rank areas for tree planting ( Figure 9 ). The top ranked locations are local residential streets , and major arterials ( e.g., 200 St and Glover Rd) . Private land ( e.g., residential areas ) and natural areas ( e.g., Portage or Nicomekl Park) w ere ranked the lowest in tree planting priority . Some respondents suggested additional priority planting areas, including industrial areas (3 respondents ), downtown Langley (2 respondents ), streams (1 respondent ), walking and biking path s (1 respondent ), floodplains (1 respondent ), and playgrounds (1 respondent ). Figure 9 . Areas where trees are missing (total respondents =154) 5% 6% 9% 10% 27% 39% 1% 14% 23% 6% 28% 28% 12% 23% 31% 9% 10% 13% 9% 34% 25% 8% 7% 16% 25% 18% 10% 32% 11% 3% 43% 5% 2% 29% 16% 1% 5% 0% 5% 1% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% In forested natural areas (e.g., Portage or Nicomekl Park) Along trails and greenways In parks On private land (e.g. residential homes, land owned by corporate or institutional landowners) Along major arterials (e.g., 200 St., Glover Rd., and Fraser Highway) Along local residential streets % of participants 1 - Most important 2 3 4 5 6 7 - Least important --- page 89 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 11 Concerns with tree loss in the City Respondents and the Committee members expressed concerns with tree loss . Respondents shared their concerns in Figure 10 . Respondents were most concerned about loss of trees due to development . Fifty two percent (52%) of participants were most concerned about mature tree loss during private development and 15% were most worried about losing public trees to make space for adjacent development . The loss of City - owned trees for capital constructions was not as much of a concern to survey respondents; o nly 2% of participants ranked it as the biggest concern for tree loss. The loss of tree to extreme weather and forest health issues is considered the lowest concern with 51% of participants ranking it the last or second last . Figure 10 . Respondents concerns with respect to tree loss in the City (total respondents = 152) Nineteen respondents provided additional responses to elaborate on their concerns. These comments centred around inadequate planning and species selection for the longevity of trees (by 8 respondents), inadequate tree management such as insufficient watering and excessive heat (by 4) , and adverse impacts of housing development on trees and natural areas such as clearing forests to accommodate development (by 5). Street tree preferences To address the loss of trees and to increase canopy over the next 30 years, Committe e members supported planting more trees in the c ity . In terms of desired tree characteristics, survey respondents prioritized trees that maximize environmental benefits, resist pests and diseases, and attract birds and pollinators with 47%, 42%, and 37% of respondents respectively ranking these as their top 2 choices. Conversely, f ood production and aesthetic value were less important with 52% and 50% of respondents ranking them as their bottom 2 choices. 2% 3% 5% 15% 18% 52% 12% 5% 21% 25% 11% 26% 21% 7% 19% 31% 13% 7% 27% 12% 15% 21% 16% 8% 29% 22% 17% 8% 19% 5% 9% 47% 20% 20% 1% 1% 4% 2% 3% 1% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Loss of trees from City-owned property for capital construction (e.g., road rebuilds, facility renewal) Loss of trees to wildfire, drought, or other extreme weather and forest health issues Homeowners removing trees on private property Removal of trees from City-owned property to accommodate adjacent development Inadequate replacement of removed trees Removal of large, mature trees from private property during development % of participants 1 - Most Concerned 2 3 4 5 6 7 - Least Concerned --- page 90 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 12 Priority actions on City - Owned Land A total of 130 r espondents shared their level of support to seven urban forestry actions on City - owned lands ( Figure 11 ). The highest priority action identified was tree planting as part of capital projects, with 82% of respondents considering it a high priority. The other actions that were considered as a high priority by over half of respondents included improving guidelines for tree species selection (67%) , s trengthening policies to protect City - owned trees ( 66 %) , and planting more trees along streets and parks (66 % ) , and expanding tree irrigation system (57%). Increasing public spending on caring for existing trees was ranked as a medium priority by 50% of respondents . Figure 11 . Respondent priority rankings for seven urban forest actions on City - owned land (total respondents = 159 ) Twenty - seven s urvey respondents provided additional open - ended comments about actions they would like to see on City - owned land , such as p reserving current large trees and habitats around waterbodies (5 respondents) , enhancing tree maintenance practices including the implementation of regular watering and inspecting schedules all trees in the City (4 respondents) , and considering planting other plants aside from where the space is not suitable for tree planting (1 respondent) . 9% 13% 6% 3% 6% 6% 50% 39% 36% 31% 26% 27% 17% 40% 46% 57% 66% 66% 67% 82% Increase public spending on tree care (e.g., watering, pruning, etc.) for existing trees to hopefully extend their lifespan Create more opportunities for residents to participate in tree planting and care, such as by watering a street tree or planting trees on City property through volunteer programs Expand irrigation systems to help protect urban trees from drought and support young tree establishment Plant more trees along streets and parks Strengthen policies to protect City-owned trees, which could include updating protection requirements, increasing enforcement, and raising penalties for unauthorized City tree damage or removal Improve guidelines for tree species selection to plant the right tree in the right place Prioritize tree planting as part of capital projects, to ensure that suitable planting sites are created in areas where trees are currently lacking Low Priority Medium Priority High Priority Not a Priority --- page 91 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 13 Priority actions on Private Property S urvey r espondents showed a high level of support for the proposed urban forestry actions on private properties ( Figure 12 ) . Among the 158 respondents who answered this question, d eveloping incentives for trees planting and increasing the planting requirements for development were the most supported actions , both ranked by 82% of respondents as a high priority action . Most respondents also considered improving guidelines for tree species ( 71 %) and enforcement measures (i.e., security deposits) for proper planting and replacement ( 69 % ) as high priority actions . Moderate level of support was shown toward actions to provide more education about tree planting and offer partnership programs with residents . Figure 12 . Respondent levels of support for six urban forest actions on private property (total respondents = 158 ) Twelve s urvey respondents provided additional open - ended comments about actions they would like to see on private property , including tree maintenance protocols that ensure regular tree inspections (3 respondent s) . Other comments reiterated the survey options on Figure 12 . Regulating private tree removals Respondents were surveyed about the extent to which the City should be involved in the removal of trees on private properties ( Figure 13 ). Forty one percent (41%) of respondents were in favour of the City having some degree of influence over tree removal , 35% supported the City having a substantial role (35%, 56 respondents) , and 16% preferred a limited level of City influence . Eight percent (8%) of respondents wished for no City involvement. 8% 10% 4% 2% 4% 3% 39% 38% 25% 26% 13% 15% 51% 51% 69% 71% 82% 82% Provide more education about tree planting and proper care Offer partnership planting programs that enable more residents to acquire and plant a tree on their property Increase refundable security deposits to ensure trees planted by development or replacement trees are planted well and inspected after development. Improve guidelines for tree species selection during development to plant the right tree in the right place Increase the number of trees that must be planted with development Develop incentives for trees to be planted as a green infrastructure solution Low Priority Medium Priority High Priority Not a Priority --- page 92 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 14 Figure 13 . Respondents’ stance on how much say the City should have in tree removal on private properties (total respondents =158) Tree regulations on private property When asked about potential private tree regulations on private property ( Figure 14 ) , most participants leaned towards either regulations that require property owners to keep most trees on their land (37% of respondents) or regulations requiring property owners to retain certain trees to uphold the community’s character (37%) . A smaller group of respondents (18 % ) supported the approach where property owners could remove trees but would need to replace the larger trees they removed, and 7% of respondents favored complete freedom without constraints on tree cutting and management decisions . Figure 14 . Respondents' preference s for tree management regulations on private property for property owners (total respondents =158) Tree regulations on private property undergoing development For private properties undergoing development ( Figure 15 ), most re spondents supported tree preservation ; 52% of respondents wanted to require property owners to maintain most trees and 37% wanted them to retain some trees to maintain the community’s character. Ten percent supported to 8% 16% 41% 35% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% None A little bit Some A lot 7% 18% 37% 37% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% Have complete freedom on what to do on their property, including removing any trees they wish Have the freedom to remove any trees they wish, but be required to plant replacement trees when they remove trees above a certain size Be required to keep some trees (for example, above a certain size) and maintain the character of the community Be required to keep most trees (meaning stricter restrictions on what they can do with their property) to preserve trees and maintain the character of the… --- page 93 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 15 have the freedom to remove trees on the condition that they replace tree above a certain size. Only 1% preferred complete freedom with an unrestricted authority over tree removal on their land. Figure 15 . Respondents’ p references for property owner undertake of tree management regulations on private property undergoing subdivision or development (total respondents = 158) 3.5 Urban forest service levels Service levels descri be how the City of Langley maintains C ity - owned tree asset s. Survey respondents were asked to rank satisfaction levels with current service levels for trees in parks and along streets. Overall, respondents had mixed levels of satisfaction with the urban forest services provided by the City ( Figure 16 ). While most respondents were satisfied with s torm response and tree debris cleanup ( 69 % satisfied versus 6 % dissatisfied) , they were more neutral about the rest of service levels, such as pest and disease control ( 39 % neutral) , and dangerous tree removal ( 34 % neutral) . Respondents were most dissatisfied with public education opportunities on urban forestry ( 9 % satisfied versus 35 % dissatisfied) and tree protection and preservation ( 21 % satisfied versus 36 % dissatisfied) . These results are in line with respondents’ major concerns discussed in the previous section. Many respondents were not aware of all the services that the City provides, especially the services for wildfire preservation and forest fuel management ( 35 % unaware), pest and disease control ( 24 %) and public education ( 24 %) . Many Committee members also expressed concerns with the lack of tree protection and interest in more tree regulations to improve protection . 1% 10% 37% 52% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% Have complete freedom on what to do on their property, including removing any trees they wish Have the freedom to remove any trees they wish, but be required to plant replacement trees when they remove trees above a certain size Be required to keep some trees and maintain the character of the community Be required to keep most trees to preserve trees and maintain the character of the community --- page 94 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 16 Figure 16 . Satisfaction levels with current service levels for trees in parks and along streets (total respondents = 155 ) Forty - five respondents provided additional comments to emphasize general disappointment with the City’s tree maintenance and planting (18 respondents ) , particularly in young tree watering and tree hazard management . Other respondents suggested solutions to improve, including: • Offer the community more tree planting , maintenance (8 respondents) • E stablish partnerships with local schools and colleges (e.g., Kwantlen Polytechnic University) on community - based urban forest planning (2 respondents) • I mprov e planting infrastructure to support growing canopies in development areas (1 respondent) • A llocating resources more strategically (e.g., budgeting financial resources proportional to the expansion of the City ; 2 respondents) • A ddress safety concerns relating to the urban forest, such as wildfire risks and homelessness along trails (2 respondents) Most r espondents were willing to contribute financially to support the City to improve the deliver y of services on public land ( Figure 17 ). Over 80% of respondents were willing to contribute $10 to $100 per household to support the delivery of satisfactory service levels on public land , while 10% of respondents prefer r e d not contributing anything . 5% 12% 5% 5% 5% 7% 9% 12% 18% 24% 30% 39% 14% 34% 29% 31% 30% 30% 33% 29% 55% 32% 19% 36% 28% 17% 7% 4% 14% 7% 6% 5% 5% 5% 24% 10% 18% 35% 14% 14% 13% 24% Pest and disease control Storm response and tree debris cleanup Dangerous tree removal Wildfire prevention and forest fuel management Tree pruning Tree planting and replacement Tree protection and preservation Public education Very dissatisfied Dissatisfied Neutral Satisfied Very Satisfied I'm not aware of this service --- page 95 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 17 Figure 17 . Respondents ’ willingness to pay for the City to deliver service levels on public land to satisfaction (total respondents = 157) 3.6 Community stewardship Community stewardship refers to activities that the community participates in to care for or contribute to urban forestry on public and private land . Seventy - nine percent o f respondents had participated in at least one urban forest stewardship activity ( Figure 18 ). The top attended stewardship activities were m aintain ing trees on personal property (79%) , planting trees on personal property (48%), assisting others with tree needs (36%) , and removing hazardous or sick tree on personal property (36%) . Other activities that respondents have participated in include e ducating friends and family about local plants to foster a connection with nature , i nquiring about the C ity’s tree policy , g etting an arborist assessment of trees , and r egularly cleaning up ravines , advocating for more C ity - planted trees in parks and streets, donating a tree to City Park, and removing invasive species. Figure 18 . Stewardship activities that respondents have participated in the past 5 years (total respondents = 157) 10% 6% 25% 20% 18% 20% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% Nothing $5 per year per household $10 per year per household $25 per year per household $50 per year per household $100 per year per household 11% 12% 17% 27% 36% 36% 48% 79% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% None of the above Planted tree(s) in a park as part of a volunteer program Reported a tree to City for inspection Watered a boulevard or park tree Removed a hazardous or sick tree on your property Assisted another person (e.g., friend, neighbour, or family member) with their tree needs Planted one or more trees on your property Maintained tree(s) on your property (e.g., watered or pruned it, or applied insecticide or tree band) --- page 96 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 18 Barriers to participating in stewardship activities R espondents cited various factors that restrict their involvement in stewardship activities ( Figure 19 ) . The top barriers cited by respondents included a lack of information about stewardship activities (43% respondents), needing permission from a strata or landlord (27%), s pace constraints ( 24% ), and already having enough trees on their property (24%) . N one of the respondents wanted no trees on their property . In addition, 6 respondents mentioned in their open - ended comments that they did not participate in stewardship activities because they had a strata management company that maintains trees for them . Figure 19 . Barriers preventing respondents from participating in stewardship activities (total respondents = 148) Encouraging factors for planting more trees on private property T o encourage residents to plant more trees on private property ( Figure 20 ) , having adequate space for planting and appropriate knowledge of species selection were important, as suggested by 41% and 39% of respondents respectively. Other approaches suggested by participants included providing a subsidy reduce planting cost (31%), offering education opportunities on tree planting and maintenance (including guidance on where to plant ; 31%), getting support from strata or landlords (30%) and information on where to buy trees ( 30%). Only 5% of respondents were not interested in planting tree on their property at all. 0% 2% 3% 3% 5% 7% 14% 14% 24% 24% 27% 43% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% I don’t want any trees on my property It requires too much physical effort I’m not interested in stewardship activities related to the urban forest I have safety concerns I have other priorities It takes too much time It is too costly I have physical or mobility challenges I don’t have enough space for a new tree I already have enough trees on my property I need permission from my strata or landlord I don’t have enough information about stewardship activities --- page 97 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 19 Figure 20 . Encourag ing factors for planting more trees on private property (total responses = 150) Thirty r espondents further provided additional comments on how to encourage tree planting on properties. Many responses reiterated results in Figure 20 . Nine respondents suggested e nsuring the proper maintenance like removing sick and dangerous trees posing threats and also having the City assure the integrity of infrastructure like private driveways or sidewalks to make them accessible for people with disability , w anting the autonomy to design their gardens by planting trees of their choice without influences (tree size, or species) , p rioritizing provisioning fruit trees , b uilding a community or neighbourhood hub to support one another with planting . 5% 17% 30% 30% 31% 31% 31% 39% 41% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% Nothing – I am not interested in planting trees on my property Having someone else plant it for me Knowing what to look for when buying a tree Support from strata or landlord Knowing where to plant a tree in my yard Education on how to plant a tree or maintain it A subsidy to reduce the cost of buying the tree Knowing what trees are suitable for our climate Having space to plant it --- page 98 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 20 4.0 Synthesis of Feedback The feedback received from the survey, mapping tool, and Committee presentation has been synthesized into key statements in the tables below. Each key statement (“What we heard”) is followed by a statement on how the feedback will be considered in relation to the ongoing development of the UFMS for the following urban forest themes: • Planning and vision • Protecting • Managing • Growing • Stewarding Summary of feedback for the urban forest planning and long - term vision What we Heard How it will be considered • Survey respondents highly valued ecological, environmental, and climate change - related benefits provided by the urban forest . • The Committee valued health and cultural benefits of the urban forest. • Respondents envisioned the City of Langley’s 2050 urban forest as expanding, with healthy trees of diverse native species that are climate suitable . • People want to see lusher and larger tree - lined streets, pathways, and trails connecting different parts of the city . The project team will incorporate this input when drafting the UFMS vision and goals to emphasize the benefits most valued by the community . Key themes for protecting the urban forest What we Heard How it will be considered More respondents were dissatisfied than satisfied by current urban forest service levels for tree protection and preservation. The draft UFMS will consider strategies aimed at enhancing tree protection and preservation. Concerns with respect to tree loss in the city are strongly associated with the removal of large mature trees in developing areas, whether on private or City - owned land, to accommodate for the C ity’s growth. The draft UFMP will consider strategies aimed at preserving existing mature trees during development and, when that is not possible, adequately replacing or compensating for the loss of trees. Many respondents expressed a desire for some form s of regulation of tree removal on private property by the City The draft UFMP will make recommendations about updates to existing regulations or new regulations that could improve tree protection, along with public awareness and incentive approaches to encourage tree retention on private property --- page 99 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 21 Key themes for managing the urban forest What we Heard How it will be considered Respondents had mixed levels of satisfaction for current urban forest service levels: • Respondents were satisfied with storm and debris cleanup and tree pruning. • Respondents expressed dissatisfaction for public education, tree protection, and wildfire prevention. • Respondents were mostly neutral about dangerous tree removal, pest and disease management, and tree planting. The draft UFMS will share information about services provided by the City and consider recommendations to improve services with the greatest dissatisfaction. Respondents notice that newly planted trees have a high mortality, possibly due to insufficient watering and excessive heat. The draft UFMP will provide information about and may recommend updates to tree management practices to improve young tree establishment. Summary of feedback for growing the urban forest What we Heard How it will be considered • Survey respondents had a strong preference for streets with mixed spacing, and either mixed or large tree sizes. • Survey respondents and mapping tool users would like to see tree planting prioritized in residential streets, along major arterials, parks, and along trails and greenways. The draft UFMP will make recommendations about tree planting to respond to those value and preferences. • On public properties, survey respondents suggested to improve planting as part of capital projects and ensure adequate planting space is created in tree - deficient areas. Respondents also would like to see a guideline for species selection following “right tree, right place” principle • On private properties, survey respondents see a tree planting incentive program and a higher tree planting requirements with development as high priority actions. The draft UFMS will provide recommendations to guide tree planting that addresses planting space improvements and capital work projects as well as opportunities to support tree planting on private land. --- page 100 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 22 Key themes from the public engagement about stewardship the urban forest What we Heard How it will be considered • Up to 124 respondents have maintained trees on private property and 19 respondents had planted at least one tree on their property in the past five years . • The largest barriers to planting trees on property were requiring permission from strata, space limitation, and already having trees. The main incentives would be having the space to plant trees, knowing which species are suitable for the climate. The draft UFMS will consider ways for the City to encourage urban forest stewardship, including education on tree planting and tree care and incentives . --- page 101 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 23 5.0 Next Steps The findings from the first phase of community engagement will inform the development of the draft UFMS, including a long - term vision and priorities for implementation. Phase 2 of public engagement is expected to occur in the fall of 2023 to gather feedback on the draft UFMS. Appendix 1 Sample Communication and Promotion Materials --- page 102 --- City of Langley Urban Forest Management Strategy – Phase 1 Engagement Summary 24 --- page 103 --- MINUTES OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY COMMITTEE Langley City Hall – CKF Room 20399 Douglas Crescent, Langley, BC THURSDAY, JUNE 13, 2024 AT 6:00 P.M. Present: Councillor Paul Albrecht, Chair Councillor Rosemary Wallace, Vice Chair Amika Watari, Post Secondary Institution Rep Armaan Lilotha, Member at Large Ellen Hall, Member at Large Lisa Boughen, Member at Large Lisa Dreves, Langley Field Naturalists Nichole Marples, Langley Environmental Partners Society Terri-Lou Trainor, LFN/Certified Bat Ambassador, Guest Presenter Staff: Kyle Simpson, Manager, Engineering & Parks Operations Natasha Loewen, Clerk, Engineering, Parks & Environment Absent: Stafford Richter, Member at Large, with regrets Zana Gordon, Member at Large, with regrets The Chair acknowledged that the land on which we gather is the traditional unceded territory of the Katzie, Kwantlen, Matsqui and Semiahmoo First Nations. 1. AGENDA It was MOVED and SECONDED THAT the JUNE 13, 2024 Agenda for the Environmental Sustainability Committee be adopted. CARRIED 2. MINUTES It was MOVED and SECONDED THAT the APRIL 11, 2024 Minutes of the Environmental Sustainability Committee meeting be adopted. CARRIED --- page 104 --- Minutes, Environmental Sustainability Committee, JUNE 13, 2024 Page 2 3. DISCUSSION 1. Bat Friendly Community Presentation 1.1. Terri-Lou Trainor presented the BC Community Bat Programs and provided an overview of bats in BC, and how to become bat friendly. 1.2. There was consensus with the committee for becoming bat friendly as the bats eat mosquitos and other insects that harm beneficial plants. 1.3. The committee discussed the favorable locations to install bat boxes/homes, such along the Nicomekl river. However, an investigation is required to determine where the bats currently live to ensure the bat boxes are built in a suitable environment. 1.4. The ESC recommends that Council pursues certification as a bat friendly community. 2. Earth Day 2024 2.1. Committee members discussed the Earth Day 2024 event, including: 2.1.1. There was positive consensus around the event, including the layout, booths, bicycle valet, and upcycle challenge. 2.1.2. The committee discussed advertising the upcycle challenge criteria to the community prior to the event. 2.1.3. It would be favorable for the community to drop off their upcycle entry at Timms Community Centre the night before the event, and display the winner(s) in the display cabinets after the event. 2.1.4. It was recognized that advanced notice and advertisement for the community would be beneficial for the 2025 event. The 2025 event to be added to the September 2024 meeting agenda for discussion. 2.1.5. LEPS to provide a summary report of the event for Council. 3. Repair-it Café 3.1. The event is scheduled for June 15 at Timms Community Centre. 3.2. LEPS is coordinating the possibility of scheduling another event at the Langley Senior Resources Society in October. 4. STANDING ITEMS N/A 5. ROUND TABLE 1. The community survey for the Economic Development Strategy is due June 24. 2. There was consensus with the committee to include the impact of urbanization on wildlife in the urban forest management assessment. 3. The committee discussed various items for the 2025 work plan, including waste management at community events, signage, and education. Committee members to research other municipal policies for consideration at the City of Langley. --- page 105 --- Minutes, Environmental Sustainability Committee, JUNE 13, 2024 Page 3 6. ADJOURNMENT It was MOVED and SECONDED THAT the meeting adjourn at 7:28 pm. CARRIED ______________________________ CHAIR Certified Correct: ______________________________ Director of Engineering, Parks & Env.